In "The Passionate Shepherd to His Love" and "The Bait" the reader locates two contrasting images of the world. Marlowe paints the earth as a utopian population withought any concerns or risks. The shepherd and the enthusiast he's seeking in his pursuit have no obligations in life other than to enjoy life to it fullest extent. In describing the pleasures that your few can enjoy in the countryside, Marlowe does not include the manner in which the shepherd obtains those pleasures and omits the negative possibilities which may go along with them. The shepherd explains to the female that they can "sit upon the rocks/And see the shepherds nourish their flocks" (5/6), but he will not mention the duties associated with buying flocks of sheep and protecting them from risk. The "beds of roses" (9) that the shepherd offers to his love will, more than likely, contain thorns and you will be a rather uneasy place to rest. To get the "gown manufactured from the best possible wool" (13) is not a fairly easy task for the shepherd because he will need to shear a lamb that involves significant amounts of hard work. The shepherd's courtship in Marlowe's poem is the impractical dream of a lover who wants to meet his desire without presenting any considered to the tasks of life in real life. Marlowe creates a fairly picture of the world, but it is far from the truth of the world resided in by the shepherd.
While Marlowe's poem occurs in an slightly imaginary world, Donne's poem portrays a more cynical and practical image of the globe. The characters in Donne's poem are in a world filled up with real risks and the likelihood of fatality. In explaining the pleasures used to tempt the fan, Donne includes the negative aspect of these pleasures. The "golden sands, and crystal brooks" (3) which can be found may be beautiful, but they do contain "silken lines, and magic hooks"(4) which may be dangerous. When Donne writes about letting "others freeze with angling reeds, /and minimize their thighs with shells and weeds (17-18), it is clear that other fish are struggling and are at risk of getting harmed in their search for love. "Strangling snare, or windowy net"( 20) is a further example of the true potential issues present for the seafood in Donne's portrayal of the world. The entire world in this poem is more sensible than the world described in Marlowe's poem; it gives thought to many of the real dangers in life. Donne creates an image of the world that is in fact close to the truth of a life lead with a fish being lured by bait.
The idea of relationship portrayed in both poems differs a great deal. Marlowe's poem expresses an overly positive view of love. He presents relationship as both beautiful and unselfish, and captures the bliss of a natural and undemanding love. The shepherd instructs the girl that if she will only, "Come live with me and become my Love" (1), he will give her delight after joy. He offers that she will be dressed up in the best possible luxuries "Fair lined household slippers for the frigid, With buckles of the purest gold (15/16) and can eat her foods from "silver meals" (21). Never, in this poem, does Marlowe acknowledge the negative aspects that are hidden in his idea of romance. He fails to mention that he is not offering her matrimony nor any recommendation that they will set up a future together. The idea of romance offered in this poem is one without any true commitment and will be offering only the pleasures of as soon as. Marlowe's view of romance catches the joys of a straightforward and uncomplicated love that is free of obligation.
Romantic love in Donne's poem is portrayed as a far more cynical experience. But the first stanzas of the poem stand for a romantic world, the remainder of the poem appears to be mocking the lifestyle of such genuine loving relationships. Donne appears to be warning men about the risks of women and of falling in love. The imagery in "Or treacherously poor seafood beset/With strangling snare, or windowy net" (19-20) illustrates a man's loss of his ability to move and be free in his search of love. It further conveys the idea that perhaps a woman is much less totally wonderful as man may believe that, and that it is the woman who is in control of the love "Each fish, which every channel hath, /Will amorously to thee swim, /Gladder to catch thee, than thou him" (10-13). The idea of romanic love portrayed in this poem is one of alert regarding the commitments and dangers that romance can hold. Donne's view of love clearly captures the down sides and complications that may be involved in relationship.
The feeling conveyed in these poems is distinctly different. Marlowe's poem signifies a feelings that is carefree and light, and Donne's represents the one which is dark plus much more serious. In Marlowe's poem, the pastoral picture creates an atmosphere of calmness and tranquility. The blissful information of love creates an enchanting feeling which makes the spirits of the poem look sensational. The treasures the shepherd offers to his love appeal to the senses and are among the most beautiful and luxurious that nature "hills and valleys, dale and field, and all that craggy mountains yield. " (3/4) and man have to offer. The animated and cheerful eye-sight that is created when the shepherd instructs the girl that "the shepherd swains shall boogie and sing" (25) if she'll accept the gifts he offers conveys a ambiance that is pleasurable and merry. The happiness and promising feeling of Marlowe's poem is within direct contrast to the darker and dangerous feelings of Donne's poem.
In Donne's poem, the disposition is dark and the individuals exist within an environment that is packed with uncertainty and laced with hazard. The pastoral scene of Marlowe's poem is substituted with the chaotic world of fish and bait alongside one another in this inflatable water. His skeptical explanation of romance creates a feeling of extreme care which fills the poem with a mood of fear and apprehension. As the seafood are completely captivated by the woman, they are willing to betray each other in order to get her love. This determination to betray each other vegetation an air of deceit into the spirits of the poem. Fear of being captured "Gladder to capture thee, than thou him" (12) suggests a disposition of anxiety in that the man needs to enjoy the bait, but does not desire to be snared by it. The possibility of the fish being caught by the bait also introduces the likelihood of death to the poem and furthers its gloomy feeling in that the fish "freeze with angling reeds" (17) or cannot move because of the "strangling snare, or windowy world wide web" (20). The dark ambiance created in this poem is significantly not the same as the bright feeling of Marlowe's poem.
My judgment that Donne's poem is written as a response to Marlowe's poem is dependant on the significant dissimilarities within the topics of the poets' portrayals of the world, their views of relationship, and the moods they occur their poems. Donne's sensible interpretation of the world is in direct compare to the idealistic world portrayed by Marlowe. In Donne's poem, it's advocated that romance is not absolutely all joy and bliss, but is serious and can be perilous. Donne's troubled and dark poem was written in response to Marlow's light and happy poem. These theme differences in the information of the world, the idea of relationship, and the disposition of the poems lead me to believe Donne's poem was written as a reply to the poem of Marlowe. This makes me feel that future poets will react to both of theses poems with the own views.