Jim in “Carnal Knowledge” and the narrator in “Battle Royal”

Both Jim in “Carnal Knowledge” and the narrator in “Battle Royal” undergo an initiation as defined by Mordecai Marcus in the essay on Blackboard. Which type of initiation do you think each underwent (be specific, using one of Marcus’s three types)? Compare and contrast their initiations, and discuss the epiphanies that each of them had. Note: you don’t have to agree with the argument I made in the lecture. Make your own case. Use direct quotations (accurately cited) from each story to support your ideas. Remember that when you “compare and contrast,” you need to go beyond discussing each story separately, but instead discuss how your analysis of the similarities and differences led you to a conclusion. Your answer should be approximately 300 words in length. What is the status of race relations in the United States at this time? How far have we come since the setting of Ellison’s story? What instances of racism or discrimination have you experienced or witnessed? What remains to be done to address this problem in our country, if you think that it remains a problem. (100 words minimum)