ASSIGNMENT ID
450461
SUBJECT AREA Law
DOCUMENT TYPE Case Study
CREATED ON 5th April 2018
COMPLETED ON 5th April 2018
PRICE
$40
9 OFFERS RECEIVED.
Expert hired: Victor Webber

case of the Speluncean Explorer. I prefer a law tutor or a writer with legal skills

The Case of the ‘Speluncean Explorers’ is an article by legal philosopher Lon Luvois Fuller that was published in 1949. It presents a legal philosophy offering five possible solutions in the form of judicial opinions that are attributed to judges sitting on the fictional ‘Supreme Court of Newgarth’ in the year 4300. In this hypothetical case, Roger Whetmore is cannibalized by his cave-exploring companions. The survivors are convicted of violating a law making it a crime that one ‘willfully take the life of another’, notwithstanding their defense of necessity. The explorers were trapped in a cave and would have died but for the sustenance of Roger Whetmore. The article offers five possible judicial responses. Each differs in its reasoning and on whether the survivors should be found guilty of breaching the law. An evenly divided Supreme Court of Newgarth affirms the convictions. Voting to affirm, Justice Keen follows the plain meaning of the statute and refuses to consider the equitable defense of necessity, while Chief Justice Truepenny urges the Chief Executive to grant clemency based upon the defense.Voting to reverse, Justice Foster argues that neither the understandings of common society nor the purpose of the statute is served by conviction, while Justice Handy votes to reverse as well, relying on virtual consensus in popular opinion. Anguished Justice Tatting - the potential tiebreaker - recuses himself because he cannot choose among the various arguments. As the Court’s decision is a tie, the original convictions are upheld and the men are sentenced to death. What should be the function of the judge in a modern democracy? Discuss, with the different positions adopted by the judges in the case of the Speluncean Explorers. Essential reading LL Fuller, ‘The Case of the Speluncean Explorers’ (1949) 62 Harvard Law Review 616. Further reading Peter Suber, The Case of the Speluncean Explorers: Nine New Opinions (London : Routledge, 1998) [electronic resource] Judge Kozinski , ‘The Case of the Speluncean Explorers: Revisited’(1999) 112 Harvard Law Review 1876. James Allan, ‘A Post-Speluncean Dialogue’ (1994) 44 Journal of Legal Education 519. LL Fuller, ‘The Case of the Speluncean Explorers’ (1949) 62 Harvard Law Review 616.
This project has already been completed on Studybay
On Studybay you can order your academic assignment from one of our 45000 project experts. Hire your expert directly, without overpaying for agencies and affiliates!
Check the price for your project

See other similar orders

Studybay assignment progress timeline

Studybay is a freelance platform where you can order a case of the Speluncean Explorer. I prefer a law tutor or a writer with legal skills paper, written from scratch by professors and tutors.
05 April 2018
User created a project for Law
05 April 2018
9 experts responded
05 April 2018
User contacted expert Victor Webber
05 April 2018
User hired expert Victor Webber who offered a price of $40 for the project and has experience doing similar projects
05 April 2018
The expert completed the project case of the Speluncean Explorer. I prefer a law tutor or a writer with legal skills for 0 day, meeting the deadline
05 April 2018
User accepted the project right away and completed the payment
05 April 2018
User left a positive review

Other projects in this subject area

Random blog posts