How can I earn money with StudyBay? Top writers
Order Assignment
This order has already been completed on Studybay
On Studybay you can order your academic assignment from one of our 45000 professional writers. Hire your writer directly, without overpaying for agencies and affiliates! Check price for your assignment
15 total offers received. Writer hired: Romulus753

Discussion 5

For this discussion, first read these two thought-experiments. Then by August 8th at 11:00 p.m., write an initial post in which you explain: 1) How you think you should have responded in the case of trolley A and the case of trolley B; 2) Why you made the decisions you did. (It may be helpful to think about how you might use one of the ethical theories learned this week to justify your answer.) You will be able to see other posts once your initial post has been submitted. Then pick two posts and respond to them. For instance, you might raise a question about a post with which you disagree, or perhaps you find something in a particular post that you found confusing or helpful in some way. Our goal is to gain a deeper sense of how our ethical intuitions affect the decisions we might make as moral agents. Trolley A: "You are standing by a railway line when you see a train hurtling towards you, out of control; the brakes have failed. In its path are five people tied to the tracks. Fortunately, the runaway train is approaching a junction with a side spur. If you flip a switch you can redirect the train onto this spur, saving five lives. That’s the good news. The not-quite-so-good news is that another person is tied down on the side spur of the track. Still, the decision’s easy, right? By altering the train’s direction only one life will be lost rather than five." Trolley B: "This time you’re on a footbridge overlooking the railway track. You see the train hurtling towards you and five people tied to the rails. Can they be saved? Again, the moral philosopher has arranged it so they can. There’s an obese man leaning over the footbridge. If you were to push him he would tumble over and squelch onto the track. He’s so fat that his bulk would bring the train—Trolley B—to a juddering halt. Sadly, the process would kill the fat man. But it would save the other five people. Should you shove him over?"
For this discussion, first read these two thought-experiments. Then by August 8th at 11:00 p.m., write an initial post in which you explain: 1) How you think you should have responded in the case of trolley A and the case of trolley B; 2) Why you made the decisions you did. (It may be helpful to think about how you might use one of the ethical theories learned this week to justify your answer.
Related Materials
Assignment ID
36485
Discipline
Type
CREATED ON
July 30, 2016
COMPLETED ON
August 1, 2016
Price
$40
This order has already been completed on Studybay
On Studybay you can order your academic assignment from one of our 45000 professional writers. Hire your writer directly, without overpaying for agencies and affiliates!
Check price for your Coursework
Latest reviews for Romulus753
epalvarez2347
December 9, 2016
epalvarez2347
Great work!!
raiderman12344
December 9, 2016
raiderman12344
Top 5 Top 5 Top 5
raiderman12344
December 7, 2016
raiderman12344
Best there is