Get help with any kind of assignment - from a high school essay to a PhD dissertation
The rights of children and the rights of parents can sometimes trigger conflict. A frequent conflict is in disagreements regarding medical therapy. The publication "The Sprit Catches You and You Fall Down" details a conflict within the medical treatment of a Hmong girl with epilepsy. Her parents' cultural and religious beliefs about medication are very different from western beliefs. The amount of those differences is detailed from the movie Split Horn which shows a shaman healer from traditional Hmong culture. The language barrier and cultural differences make it impossible for Lia's parents to comprehend her physicians. They often interfere with the medical care which Lia desperately needs due to their spiritual beliefs and misunderstanding. Society, however, has a stake in protecting every child. Ours is a secular society which relies on modern medicine to guarantee children's health. Due to this, we do not place the spiritual beliefs of parents above the shared responsibility of protecting a child's wellbeing. Parents don't have the right to refuse medical treatment for their son or daughter. Parents' religious beliefs must be respected by culture but a kid can not truly belong to a religion until he or she has reached adulthood and chose to believe. Therefore, decisions regarding medical care ought to be rational and logical. Lia's conflict is the result of two cultures colliding: the traditional Hmong culture and the American culture. It is made of speaking English, with at least a high school education, and trusting and obeying authority figures like doctors. A Native American household would have the ability to communicate and understand physicians. They would have a fundamental comprehension of science and the human body. This would give them the un...