Get help with any kind of project - from a high school essay to a PhD dissertation
|Subject area||Arts Entertainment|
"Dunkirk has been a fantastic deliverance and a great tragedy" - (AJP Taylor) Is there adequate evidence in resources A to F to confirm this interpretation? Use the resources and knowledge from your studies to explain your response AJP Taylor gave this quote from his novel "English history" that was printed in 1965. It says that Dunkirk was a great deliverance; this entails how the troops were saved and successfully sent shape the development of the German Army. However the disaster is speaking undeniably to the more disguised details of Dunkirk, like the excellent military overcome, the thousands of bits of equipment and the 1.2 million inmates taken by the Germans. The sources have a broad variety of media, Source A being a painting and are less reliable due to it being only an artist's impression of occasions. Sources B and C are images from the battle so they'll show a much more accurate picture, although they only reveal a single instance in time. Source D is an extract of an address from the Union for war, Source E is an article from The Daily Express, and therefore it is likely to contain some gathered information about the occasion. Source F is an extract from a book by AJP Taylor enclosing the quotation making up the title that's useful for viewing the context in which the quotation was made. Some resources are certainly more valuable than the others, for their informative nature and absence of bias, such as origin F is composed by a historian more than twenty years after the event allowing for a large amount of research to be accumulated and compiled for such a job, However source D has a massive quantity of prejudice and difficult vocabulary therefore limiting its usefulness in supporting the claim by Taylor. Another variable at discovering...