The Characteristics Nurture Debate Psychology Essay

In the history of psychology one of the oldest quarrels is the Nature-Nurture issue with regard to what makes us human beings not the same as each-other: our genes or the environment, and which of these attributes contributes more to a person's internal and physical development.

The Characteristics -Nurture controversy was presented in the past due IX Century by one of the first experimental psychologists Francis Galton in his "English men of research: Their Dynamics and Nurture" (1874). With this work he message or calls mother nature and nurture, "a convenient jingle of words, for this separates under two particular heads the many components of which personality is made up. Aspect is all a man brings with himself into the world; nurture is every affect that impacts him after his beginning" (p. 12).

Philosophers in ancient times, such as Plato, presumed that a child was created with some innate knowledge. Locke however, was an empiricist and thought that the mind at labor and birth was a "blank slate"-with a clear brain and no abilities.

Certain physical attribute are biologically dependant on genetic inheritance such as pigmentation of epidermis and color of eye which are obtained by the genes we inherit. Additional physical characteristics such as level, weight, hair thinning even some conditions (e. g. breasts cancer in women) seem to be influenced by the genetic make-up of the parents. These facts have made many to ask the question whether psychological characteristics such as cleverness, gender, personality and tendencies are product of your genes or they may be influenced by the environment.

The following issue looks at whether we acquire quite a few traits through mother nature, or through our environment- nurture related to our cleverness and gender.

The case of heredity (character) as a disagreement to the debate can be traced back to Charles Darwin's theory of development and the thought of "survival of the fittest" influencing the Biological strategy in Mindset which focuses on genetic and hormonal explanation of action and tends to favor the type aspect of the nature-nurture argument. The nature way view claims that lots of individuals skills and actions are consequence of genetically inherited urges (e. g. intellect, personality, maternal instinct) which is supported by nativists. On the other hand the view that supports the fact that human being main skills and characteristics are socially learned and developed through experience is the view of empiricists, regarding to whom whatever we learn we learn trough perception.

The subject of Brains is one of the major passions within Psychology and incredibly difficult to determine as it is subject matter of many subconscious factors as: capacity to cope with all aspects of daily living, problem fixing skills, learning and profiting from previous experiences, predicting likely final results and many more skills that humans use to change themselves to their environment. Good reasoning ability, rationalization and cognitive skills seem to be to further develop intellect.

An influential theory of the natural bases of intelligence is the theory that the base of intelligence is in the brain (Donald Hebb 1949). This theory advises the need of distinguishing among different intelligences: Intelligence A as innate probable which is biologically identified and represents the capability for development. Intelligence B is the functioning of the brain and is produced when brains A interacts with the surroundings. Philip E. Vernon (1979) elaborated this definition to include intellect C, which is the credit score one obtains with an brains test. Hebb's point of view is that the essential potential for intellectual development is provided by the genes and the arousal because of this potential to be reached is environmentally provided.

Early psychologists, such as Sir Francis Galton, described intelligence in terms of simple sensory, perceptual, and electric motor responses, as opposed to higher mental processes such as thinking and problem dealing with. Galton's main contribution was that he elevated questions about specific differences in cleverness and how it should be assessed.

He believed that intelligence is innate something we are blessed with.

In 1905 Alfred Binet and his university student Theofile Simon released one of the first measuring intellect test called the Binet-Simon level. They developed the concept of mental get older to measure the individual's degree of mental development in accordance with others. For instance a child with a mental capacity of a standard five calendar year old has a mental level (age group) of five, so an eight calendar year old with a mental age of five is 'deficient'. Using Binet's ideas and computations, William Stern developed the cleverness quotient (IQ). The IQ is a thought measured by dividing a person's mental years by his/her chronological get older and multiplying by 100.

The current version of the initial IQ test is named the Stanford-Binet and it can be administered as early as era 2 and through adulthood. It has been revised to assess skills in four areas: verbal reasoning, quantitative reasoning, abstract/visual reasoning, and short-term storage area. Cleverness quotient is the most typical measure of brains, but could it be the most correct and can it measure all the types of cleverness that people maintain. Is it valid and reliable pertaining to different ethnicities and environmental factors. Not, for example intelligent tests suitable for middle income white children do not represent the principles and early activities of children in other ethnicities, meaning they are really culturally biased. However it is proved that a lot of intelligence exams have high trustworthiness with a relationship coefficient of +90 and IQ scores are a good predictors of success in school, e. g. the verbal scale of the Weschler exams correlated with university grades.

Twin studies are most likely the ultimate way to assess the influence of genes and the environment in determining individual differences in intellect. Because similar twins (MZ) come from a single fertilized egg that splits in two, they show practically the same genetic code which means they are really of the same intimacy and they should look very much alike. By comparing fraternal twins (DZ), (who come from individual eggs and share on average 1 / 2 their DNA) with identical twins, research workers can identify the level to which our genes have an effect on our intellect. If identical twins have significantly more similar IQ ratings than fraternal twins, there will be a reasonable conclusion that heredity influences intelligence. The many studies taken by research workers regarding cleverness use these different degrees of genetic marriage as a basis because of their hypothesis. It ought to be the case that the better the kinship the more similar individuals should be, if this characteristic looked into is inherited.

Some of the evidence encouraging the genetically inherited brains comes from the twin studies. For example, by looking at many twin studies Bouchard and Mc Gue(1981) discovered that identical twins raised in various environment generally have more similar IQ scores than the fraternal twins reared together. These findings suggest that there's a strong genetic element of IQ and helps the heredity point of view. If the surroundings was a key point, the fraternal twins' IQ ratings should have experienced closer correlation. However there exists few criticisms of the twin studies, Leon Kamin for example criticizes Shield's twin analysis professing that the twins in the analysis were actually brought up by family e. g. one twin by the mother and the other by the grandmother, aunt or other relation. They distributed the same environment by going to the same school and surviving in the same neighborhood. Another more general criticism of the twin studies would be the tiny examples of twins actually found in the studies and the method of recruiting them e. g. advertising in the mass media therefore each test was self-selected. Previous criticism would be that MZ twins aren't exactly identical, partly because of small genetic dissimilarities and also because they create their own microenvironment.

The Adoption studies provide an alternative option to investigate the effects of heredity and environment in intelligence, by comparing followed children's intelligence to that of these adoptive family and of these natural parents. Adopted children promote 50 % of their biological parents' genetics and none of the environment, while they promote no genes plus some environment using their adoptive parents. Hence any similarity diagnosed between adopted children's IQ and either their real or adoptive family would suggest which one of these factors nurture or character, performs more important role in human's intelligence.

The Texas Adoption Project-Horn(1983) engaged almost 500 children, the conclusions of wich demonstrated that followed children's IQ's were more strongly correlated with their natural rather than adoptive mother(0. 28 weighed against 0. 15)though dissimilarities were small. Years later when the children were older these were tested again and the results exhibited, increased IQ correlation with their biological mothers and reduced one with the implemented family especially during past due adolescence (Bouchard, 1997; McGue, Bouchard, Iacono, & Lykken, 1993). The adoption studies show that shared environment became less important and hereditary factors turned out to be more important as the kids became older. The results of this analysis outlines the importance of the family environment and the impact it offers on the introduction of children's brains.

Another essential study to note is the Job Headstart that was desighned to boost intelligence of disadvantaged children, through environmental imput and tended to provide more stimulating culturaly enriched program for these people and compare their IQ before and following the program. It was argued however that such children lacked some of the early benefits relished by more of the middle-class children. For example intellectual excitement and health insurance and therefore they were disatvantiged even before they started out institution. Such disatvantages may lead to possible failure. When the childrens were weighed against a control group they exhibited modest intellectual advancements, however these benefits were short- lived. The outcomes of Project Mind Start provide strong support for the short-term efficiency, demonstrating how important is the intellectuall activation at home and reveals that intellect can be influenced by environmental factors.

Gender is a emotional term which identifies several charachteristics or qualities and determines what a woman or a man is in social and biological aspect. In other words gender identifies the personal idea of being female or male regardless of an individual's natural and outward intimacy. Although we live born with our making love which is a lot more obvious biological difference between a male and a lady, we have to find out about our gender.

Biological sex is set at conception by the pairing of chromosomes that can either be XX for females and XY for guys. Gender however is a socially influenced term very much dependant on culture, ideas, goals, stereotipes and behaviour regarding someone's sex. As well as the nature nurture debate, the main topic of gender and making love is widely talked about, where the notion that gender variations are dependant on genes and hormones is at favorof the the nature aspect of the debate and it is reinforced by the biological and psychoanalitical approach. Thus any gender differences are assumed to be innate. Alternatively nurture refers to the theory that gender variations are due to cultural and cultural factors. Hence these dissimilarities are due to the environment. This is the behaviorist's and cognitive approaches.

Sex human hormones determine the physical development of men and women. The main girl human hormones are called

estrogens, and androgens are the primary male hormones.

A study taken by Money and Ehrhardt (1972) on females who have been subjected to high levels of male sex hormones prenatally, noted that these were acting more like a boys somewhat than young ladies. They preferred to try out with blocks and cars rather than with dolls even though their parent or guardian cured them as women. These results provide evidence for biological influences in the variations between the sexes.

However Money and Ehrhardt (1972)concluded from further twin studies that gender is socially alternatively than biologically built. They studied men equivalent twins, one of whom sexual organ's was greatly damaged, anticipated to surgical treatment. Money recommended the parents of the youngster, that the best answer would be to raise the youngster as a girl, with additional way to obtain female hormones at puberty. The parents brought up the guy as a girl calling him Brenda and worthwhile him with a gender appropriate behavior. Money reported that Brenda used dolls and behaved just like a girl whereas his twin brother preferred boy's gadgets. Although Money used these study to argue that social factors can domineer biology, later studies Colapinto(2000)( Brenda chose to be a male and committed) proved that mother nature may become more important in identifying gender.

Criticism of these studies, which are and only the nurture part of the question, would be having less reason of the impact of social factors and environment on gender development, such as woman's area and health nourishment during her motherhood. Also the attained studies from Money and Ehrhardt (1972) cannot be universal for the overall inhabitants, e. g. the evidences have been extracted from very unusual conditions.

An opposing to the type view of natural inheritance in gender is the cross-cultural study of anthropologist Margaret Mead. She researched various societies in New Guinea the studies of which support the sociobiological theory. Margaret mead uncovered a different pattern of male and female behavior in each of the cultures she analyzed, noticing some gender dissimilarities, but also gender similarities. The Aparesh Indians both men and women were responsive, delicate and cooperative which in western society would be more commonly associated with females way of behavior. On the list of Mundugumor tribe, both men and women were violent and extreme, seeking ability and position. For the Tchambuli the females behaved in a self-confident and indie manner, being in charge and oppositely the males were less liable and more psychologically dependent. Mead's finding contribute to the advice that environment or social learning in expanding gender roles takes on crucial part and only the nurture side of the issue, even if there are genetic or hormonal dissimilarities between the sexes. However Mead's work has been criticized for the validity of her study and if the results she reported weren't made, to allow them to support her theory.

In contradiction with Mead's theory, John Bowlby argues that some variations in the behaviour and habit of men and women are genetically transmitted instincts. For instance Bowlby argued that females will need to have maternal instincts and "the role of caregiver is merely something which women are blessed with" (p. 277).

The psychoanalytical theory of Sigmund Freud suggested biological factors and the social environment as determining influences on the child gender-role development. Biological factors - erotic energy which is channeled to the various zones of the body during development. Social environment - how the kid is cured by the parents.

According to Freud gender role development starts through the phalic phase (3-6 years). Throughout that stage a child encounters a biologically structured love for the parent of the contrary gender-the Oedipus complicated in boys and Electra organic in girls. Nevertheless the child experiences issue and anxiety as a result of these forbidden wishes and so that they can resolve the discord she or he identifines with the parent or guardian of the same gender. Therefore gender -role

Development begins as a result of children's recognition with the same gender parent or guardian. This process according to F occurs on the unconscious level and therefore can't be managed by either the parent or guardian or the kid. F argued that if the mom or the father behaved in an unappropriate because of their gender model the kid respectively would not acquire appropriate gender role

According to sociable learning theory children learn gender appropriate behaviour trough observation and modeling (imitation) of others in their society(e. g. Bandura, 1977) and from that contemporary society media visibility. Many parents encourage their children to react appropriately and strengthen them when they do so. A good example in support that view is

Beverly Fagot's (1989) longtitudinal research on children as young as get older of 2. Their parents had to encourage gender appropriate action and on the other side to discurrage gender inapropriate behaviour. For example young ladies were encouraged that can be played with dolls and discouraged to climb trees. The results of the study showed that some parents did show their children how to behave in gender-sterotyped way.

  • More than 7,000 students prefer us to work on their projects
  • 90% of customers trust us with more than 5 assignments
submit a project

Latest posts

Read more informative topics on our blog
The Educational Curriculum INSIDE THE Philippines Education Essay
Education The educational curriculum in the Philippines is low in comparison to other countries. Other countries are able to find out more advanced...
The Ecotourism In Scotland Travel and leisure Essay
Tourism Hospitality and travel and leisure are very closely linked; every time a tourist comes to Scotland there are lots of restaurant and hotels to...
Corporate Social Responsibility: Targets and Concepts
Business Abstract Corporate Social Responsibility is a management principle whereby companies integrate social and environmental concerns in their...
A Personal Reflection AROUND THE ITM Information Technology Essay
Information Technology I have been in information technology industry for a long time. I have first-hand information technology experience especially in...
The Theory Of Mcdonaldization Commerce Essay
Commerce McDonaldization is the process where the concepts of the junk food industry have come to dominate an increasing variety of organizations in...
The Interpretation Of Life Quotes
Philosophy As you all know most of us are here in this planet for a while only and our life or being blessed as a individuals is a gift irrespective of...
The Sex Appeal In Advertising Mass media Essay
Media Through the years we have found a diversity advertising resources for offering products which were calling the attention of the costumers, to be...
Impacts of Tourism Deregulation and National Security
Marketing National security is definitely an issue going out with back to as early as when man started out arranging himself in contemporary society....
Homogeneous And Differentiated Product In Microeconomics Economics Essay
Economics The economic issue in this observation involves the concept of homogeneous and differentiated product in microeconomics According to Lindeman...
Check the price
for your project
we accept
Money back
100% quality
Plagiarism free writing service