The Conflict Between Manmade Rules And Natural Rules Philosophy Essay

When Agamemnon is required to return Chryseis back again to her daddy, he gives an ultimatum declaring that he would only do this if he gets Briseis in trade. This infuriates the mighty Achilles beyond control (hence the aforementioned estimate) who then continues on to confront Agamemnon. This where the whole issue of manmade rules vs. natural law is necessary, because in book I, Agamemnon is described as 'a powerful man who lords it over all the Argives, one the Achaeans must follow' A mighty ruler', Achilles on the other hand, is expressed as the 'matchless runner'. This shows us that even though by regulations of dynamics, Achilles ought to be the person who is in control, but by the right of delivery, Agamemnon is the one in complete vitality. When endeavoring to explain the difference in manmade regulation vs. natural legislation, the difference is very straightforward. There are certain rules in modern culture that people have to abide by in order for harmonious living. These are basic norms and principles that are drilled into us from years as a child through various types of socialization such as university, family etc. Included in these are various polices such as respect, love and also to value those who are near and dear to us. In college we have various sanctions enforced on us if we break any of the place norms such as cheating or skiving course for no noticeable reason. For much more serious offences such as murder, scam or theft, various providers of social control can rein in these 'unnatural' wants by putting us into remand homes or jail. Furthermore, within a country we are given certain human rights which we can exercise on a regular basis such as flexibility of speech, right to equal safeguard under the law etc. When new regulations are set up within a culture, we say these guidelines are manmade, as these do not comes normally to us.

Natural law is the fact that "unwritten laws" that is more or less the same for everyone everywhere. To become more exact, natural laws is the concept of a body of moral ideas that is common to all humankind and, as generally posited, is recognizable by individual reason together. Natural regulation is therefore recognized from-and offers a standard for- manmade legislation, the formal legal enactments of a particular society. Since laws are made for a reason; natural law can be used to dictate individuals reason. Actually, it is legislation discovered by real human reason. Our normal and natural knowledge of the natural legislation is affected by reason, that is, by the pondering head, and in this service reason is sometimes called "conscience. " We, in every our human works, undoubtedly see them in their relation to the natural rules, and we emotionally pronounce after their arrangement or disagreement with the natural laws. Such a pronouncement may be called a "judgment of conscience. " The "norm" of morality is the natural legislations as applied by conscience. Lastly, we can say that the natural rules is the disposition of things as known by our real human reason and which we should conform ourselves if we are to realize our proper end or "good" as humans. So in a more concise form, we can say that natural law is the fact that by human beings can rationally guide themselves with their good.

The origins of natural law theory lie in Ancient Greece. Many Greek philosophers mentioned and codified the idea of natural laws, and it played out an important role in Greek authorities. Later philosophers such as St. Thomas Aquinas, Thomas Hobbes, and John Locke built on the work of the Greeks in natural laws theory treatises of their own. Many of these philosophers used natural laws as a construction for criticizing and reforming manmade laws, arguing that manmade lawful restrictions which are unjust under the key points of natural legislations are legally hoping. Some theorists dispute that humans can provide up certain privileges to are in world, for the better individuals good. However, the basic tenets of equality and a desire to do good still stay. Some individuals also integrate religious beliefs into natural law theory, while some refer more generally to basic moral laws which may or may not be led by religious trust. To really understand the basis of the natural rules theory, we must go back in time, as Aristotle was the pioneer in discovering this theory. In early Greece, the emphasis on the difference between 'character' (physis, ?'???) and 'rules', 'custom', or 'convention' (nomos, ?'???) was made apparent from the start. It basically supposed that even although rules of the land can vary greatly from location to place, but 'by aspect' they must be the same everywhere. Resistant to the conventionalism that the variation between nature and custom could create, Socrates and his philosophic heirs, Plato and Aristotle, put forward the lifestyle of natural justice or natural right.

Going back to explaining natural laws and manmade regulation in the Iliad, we can plainly start to see the disproportion in the rates within the army. Achilles, who's the son of the goddess Thetis, is manufactured the leader of the Achaean's whereas Agamemnon is the commander-in-chief and is a mere mortal. Furthermore, we note that Achilles is self-less and commendable, while Agamemnon is self-centered and egotistical. Proof this is evident when Achilles was created to give up his award (Briseis) because Agamemnon needs it in substitution for sending again Chryseis. Achilles is enraged by the question and argues that the plunder has already been allocated and a good man does not take back what he has given. Agamemnon and Achilles dispute, each man insulting the other. Agamemnon threatens to have a prize if is not given to him, and Achilles reminds him that of the Achaeans are fighting against foes who have only wronged Menelaus. With regard to the two royal brothers, the Argives bloody their hands against men who've done them no incorrect. Achilles also complains that though he bears the heaviest burden in battle, it is the king who is always greedy for prizes. Achilles refuses to fight ever again as he'll go home to Phthia. Because of this dishonor, anger seizes Achilles and he strides toward Agamemnon to kill him. Hera sends the goddess Athena to avoid him. Only Achilles can easily see Athena, who says him never to kill the ruler. She guarantees that Achilles will be justly compensated for this great dishonor and Achilles obeys her. That is itself is a trait to be noted, even though Achilles is seething with trend and a interest to demolish Agamemnon there and then, he restraints himself because he's instructed by a goddess and shown that even though he may be stronger and much more virtuous of both, Agamemnon continues to be the king and thus he must be obeyed unconditionally.

Manmade law is made for the betterment of mankind. Man does know this legislations, makes this law, and therefore has the capacity to break this legislation, or amend it, or delete it. In the Iliad, we can see that Agamemnon not only twists and converts the law to his benefits but even will try to 'test' his army, just so they can be comfortable that his army still will pay him the kind of respect demanded by way of a ruler, unquestionable and undeniable. This is seen when Thetis, pleads with Zeus to intervene and bring the challenge between your two mighty warriors to an end. Zeus then involves Agamemnon in his fantasy, but Agamemnon manipulates it to his benefit. We also observe the obvious difference between Achilles and Agamemnon, when Nestor, oldest of the Achaean kings, rises and tells both men that they need to pay attention to him, because he's old and has lived and fought with warriors higher than any now living. He asks Agamemnon never to take Briseis, Achilles' quite won reward, and he tells Achilles that he must value Agamemnon's position as commander-in-chief. His words are lost on both men. Achilles returns to his ships with his partner Patroclus. The Achaeans send the boats to make the sacrifice, with Odysseus in charge of the expedition. In the meantime, Agamemnon transmits men to fetch Briseis, who is given up without a fight Achilles will not resist because the lady was a surprise written by Agamemnon and the great warrior feels it is not his spot to refuse the king. This clearly implies that if Achilles sought, he might have struck down Agamemnon with no effort and still has his military, but he choose to obey the law of the land and comply with the rule of obeying one's king. Agamemnon on the other side, misused and abused his ability and took what was not his and behaved in ways not fitted for a ruler.

As per positivists like Rousseau (1754), there is absolutely no legislations unless we create it, which is true in the sense that we now have no social effects of our actions unless contemporary society has agreed to implement such effects. The idea of "natural legislation" suggests that there are causes acting after man that are beyond change. Although there are evident examples of "scientific" natural law, like the rules of gravity, there are definitely more subtle examples including the laws that stealing from your neighbor will cause hardship you and others. Regarding to D'entreves (1954) 'Natural Rules is binding beyond the will of any material being, man included'. What this is wanting to imply is the fact natural law exists even without the lifetime of man, and even as background shows us, natural laws did exist well before man, and even life generally. Manmade laws and regulations are culturally and psychologically described, in no way can they be perplexed with natural regulation. The line between 'natural' and 'manmade' legislations must be drawn between those laws which were consciously created and those which exist slightly by default'. Yves R. Simon says that 'natural regulation cannot be shattered. Moral sentiments seem to be to be natural rules because our morality leads us to believe egocentrically about it'. Manmade laws is also called 'positive legislations' in many contexts, the reason this is so is because they are typically "imposed" on the people of a specific area. There are numerous arguments that time towards the actual fact that positive regulation is always spiritual in characteristics, for example 'The Ten Commandments of Christianity'; Christians might consider the Ten Commandments valid not only because they are rooted in moral principles, but also because they could have been etched in stone by God. This view is recognized by the actual fact that positivists think that in order for a rules to be obeyed, it must be endorsed by a person in power. Ethics are occasionally woven into positive rules, but behaving in an unethical way is not necessarily considered a violation of the law. For example, it may be considered unethical for a organization to minimize revenue because of its own gain; however, if this behavior is conducted under the suitable positive legislation, it may not be outlawed.

Besides, another theory that comes through by many sociologists such as Novak mentioned that synthetic law has actually stemmed from natural legislations. The example he offered because of this is that of traffic rules, what could be the reason for looking both ways before crossing a streets? The response was simple he argued, every human being gets the 'natural' instinct of staying alive and will try to avoid any situation is which their life is in peril. Behaving in virtually any other way, would result in altruistic behavior, i. e. to be able to encourage oneself, behaving in a manner that is selfless and detrimental. Going back to examining the implications of the conflict between manmade regulation and natural legislation in Publication I of the Iliad, we can now look into it with a more educated perspective. Achilles behaved in an honorable way because one reason may be that he may want to remain true to his personal code of ethics or second he might be doing this, so that he still codes the same sort of esteem from his subordinates as before. We ought to please note however, that even though Achilles' trend is famous, one expression from Athena calmed him enough to restrain himself. The word 'your freedom ends where my nose area commences' can be aptly applied to this particular situation. This is because even though Agamemnon openly slighted Achilles before the entire military and exhibited him who was simply in control, Achilles ignored it.

Adler, in his works, once said that 'natural legislations means concepts of human conduct, not the regulations of nature learned by the physical sciences'. According to him, 'the natural legislation as put on physical things or family pets is sacred; superstars and atoms never disobey the laws of their mother nature. But man often violates the moral rules which constitute the law of his specific human being aspect'. For e. g. Plato phone calls it "justice" and can be applied it to the human being soul and individual do. The first precept of natural regulation is to get the good and steer clear of evil. It is often put as follows: "Do good unto others, injure no one, and render to every man his own. " Now, of course, such a general principle is inadequate for organized contemporary society unless we can put it to use to specify numerous kinds of privileges and wrongs. That is just what man-made, or positive, laws attempts to do. Thus, the natural legislation instructs us only that stealing is wrong because it inflicts injury, however the positive laws of larceny defines the various kinds and levels of robbery and prescribes the punishments. Such particular determinations varies in a variety of times and places without affecting the principles of natural law. Neither Aquinas nor Aristotle thinks that particular rules of laws ought to be the same in different times, places, and conditions.

In the Iliad, the implications of pitting synthetic regulation versus natural rules can be many. Achilles refused to fight in the battle from the Trojans, because his take great pride in was wounded during his personal fight against Agamemnon. He vowed that he would not struggle Hector, best warrior of the Trojans, and thus avenge his harm when he see's Agamemnon street to redemption dismally to the ground. If Agamemnon had not exercised his right as the supreme ruler, this would not have happened and he, with the aid of mighty Achilles, would have extended his victorious streak against Troy. In conclusion, it is not hard to note that due to various rules drawn out for all of us in contemporary society, expressing our true sentiments can be difficult. Even Achilles, the matchless runner, were required to suppress his fury because choosing his instinct would bring embarrassment and pity to himself. Finally, for me, the have an effect on of manmade laws in world is much larger than that of natural laws and regulations. We view it in everyday activity even, we can always look to people in ability e. g. politicians and find out that its not necessarily the smartest or most virtuous person who is elected to power, more times than not, individuals in charge of our life are those who are already moneyed or have enough financial stability to invest in their next three generations. Hence the 'laws' that are put into impact only advantage them and their allies. The Iliad was used as a instruction manual for generations and people still look to it for moral lessons, this is because though it took place hundreds of years ago, the fundamental message is still well founded for today's society.

Natural Rules Vs. Manmade Legislations 3

  • More than 7000 students trust us to do their work
  • 90% of customers place more than 5 orders with us
place an order

Latest posts

Read more informative topics on our blog
The Educational Curriculum INSIDE THE Philippines Education Essay
Education The educational curriculum in the Philippines is low in comparison to other countries. Other countries are able to find out more advanced...
The Ecotourism In Scotland Travel and leisure Essay
Tourism Hospitality and travel and leisure are very closely linked; every time a tourist comes to Scotland there are lots of restaurant and hotels to...
Corporate Social Responsibility: Targets and Concepts
Business Abstract Corporate Social Responsibility is a management principle whereby companies integrate social and environmental concerns in their...
A Personal Reflection AROUND THE ITM Information Technology Essay
Information Technology I have been in information technology industry for a long time. I have first-hand information technology experience especially in...
The Theory Of Mcdonaldization Commerce Essay
Commerce McDonaldization is the process where the concepts of the junk food industry have come to dominate an increasing variety of organizations in...
The Interpretation Of Life Quotes
Philosophy As you all know most of us are here in this planet for a while only and our life or being blessed as a individuals is a gift irrespective of...
The Sex Appeal In Advertising Mass media Essay
Media Through the years we have found a diversity advertising resources for offering products which were calling the attention of the costumers, to be...
Impacts of Tourism Deregulation and National Security
Marketing National security is definitely an issue going out with back to as early as when man started out arranging himself in contemporary society....
Homogeneous And Differentiated Product In Microeconomics Economics Essay
Economics The economic issue in this observation involves the concept of homogeneous and differentiated product in microeconomics According to Lindeman...
Check the price
for your assignment
we accept
  • Visa payment system
  • MasterCard payment system
  • Payoneer payment system
  • PayPal payment system
Money back
100% quality
Plagiarism free writing service