We accept

Study Of Warning sign Management Strategies For Palliative Care Medical Essay

This essay revolves around Claire, her symptoms, her capacity to cope as well as her hubby Andrew. More exactly, it will focus on strategies which can be employed for indicator management.

Central to any form of management strategy for Claire is a all natural assessment of her circumstances followed by planning, execution and evaluation. This may often be accomplished by with the help of an examination model which are all, to a huge extent, broadly based on this course of action, but each can analyse the problem from another type of point of view. (Fawcett J 2005)

If one first considers the situation under the aegis of the Roper Logan Tierney model (Roper, Logan & Tierney 2000), this model analyses the major issues of patient management in terms of fixing the patient's complications in adapting to and coping with daily living, particularly if such coping is afflicted by the physical disability or an illness process. In conditions of those with malignant disease, this is plainly one of the major issues. Even a brief overview of the literature shows that this model is extensively utilised and is possibly one of the very most widely accepted types of patient management (Holland, Jenkins, Solomon & Whittam 2003). One of the major weakness of the model can be seen in the actual fact that it's not particularly effective in producing management strategies that can be effective in working with patients who are frankly manipulative or are delivering with symptoms that are overtly mental in aspect. Whilst there is no advice that Claire is overtly manipulative, Johnson factors to the actual fact that the management of mental issues in palliative care and attention is every bit as central to a successful outcome, as coping with ostensibly more obvious indicator features such as pain control (Johnson 1999. )

Management of such patients can be better if the doctor views such useful behavior as a adaption process to the condition role as referred to by the Roy adaption model. (Roy 1991) which looks for to describe patient behaviour in conditions of the power of the individual to adapt to whatever stimulus is creating the behaviour. Regarding the patient with malignant disease, understanding of a terminal medical diagnosis is a strong stimulus for behavior change.

Utilisation of the model permits the nursing management decisions to respond to the changing trajectory of the condition. This model can prove useful insofar as it establishes why the individual tends to display different behaviour habits or coping strategies in response with their health problems trajectory but it is of no real value in circumstances in which a patient enters a period of overt denial of their terminal situation. To use Claire as a good example, any difficulty. she is presenting her symptoms individually rather than as part of a spectrum associated with the primary pathophysiological cause. It is not unusual, in such circumstances, for a person to present with a sickness that is obviously terminal, but who insists on attempting to keep their daily life pattern as if there was no immediate problem.

To a qualification, her manifestation of surprise at the actual fact that folks have "come out of the woodwork" to visit her can be an demonstration of this fact. As opposed to the other two models talked about, the adaption model would summarize this as a variety of cognitive distortion alternatively than overt denial. Plainly the individual cannot adapt to something they are choosing not to overtly confront. (Steiger & Lipson 2005) Claire appears to be somewhere between these two eventualities. Obviously she is aware of her identification, but is expressing wonder that folks would all of the sudden want to go to her. The Johnson's behavioural model may possibly be the most likely for this scenario as Claire's behavior pattern will likely change as her symptomatology progresses. It comes after that one has to take a view on the precise causation of the symptoms before one can take a logical view of the data base assisting any management strategies.

Prior to the effective consideration of the management of the symptoms, in the context of the behavioural style of patient management, one must touch upon the huge spectrum of skills and requirements that are currently expected of the modern professional nurse. Yura et al. condition, in their authoritative guide paper, that to be practical and effective the nurse must "understand the real human condition from the viewpoint of the pathophysiology, the mindset, the human dynamic and socio-economic elements of the patient's demonstration and disease trajectory ". (Yura & Walsh 2008). In Claire's circumstance, this is specially appropriate.

In conditions of exploring the evidence base for indication control. If one uses a biomedical symptom model, then your only significant symptoms are increasing breathlessness, coughing and fatigue. There is also an element of sleeping disorders which leads to tiredness throughout the day. Other, harder to determine symptoms, which nevertheless stem from the root pathophysiology, but aren't generally referred to in biomedical conditions, include her feeling of insufficient control of her life, and, by inference there may be the problem of her increasing reliance on her man, Andrew.

If one considers the data basic for symptomatic treatment, one should preferably first consider the four principal sizes of palliative care as outlined by Cicely Saunders because they are particularly highly relevant to Claire, particularly the physical, communal, spiritual and mental dimensions. (Saunders & Regnard 1989). It comes after that, although this article will primarily consider symptomatic treatment of breathlessness, it must be realized that should be supplied within the framework of the alternative assessment of the individual discussed in the first paragraphs of this essay. In the words of Valente et al. , "The individual, whole and whole, has family members, friends, values and previous encounters all of which must be integrated into management strategy. " (Valente & Saunders 2010 Pg 25)

Breathlessness, as a particular symptom, is the consequence of a complex connection between your physical body and the mindful mind. It is the most commonly reported symptom found in relationship with lung cancer and one of the most possibly distressing. (Knower, Dunagan, Adair & Chin 2007). Breathlessness, unlike the pain commonly associated with malignancies, is difficult to treat with any degree of success. The huge information level IIb Higginson trial of lung malignancy patients clearly demonstrated that the prevalence of breathlessness increased as death contacted which treatment became steadily more inadequate (Higginson & McCarthy 2008). In another large potential research level IIb analysis by Edmonds et al. it was found that although clinicians and patients both tend to associate lung cancers mostly with pain, breathlessness has a similar incidence to the degree that 85% patients with lung tumors experienced pain and 78% had significant breathlessness in the last year with their life. (Edmonds, Karlsen, Khan & Addington-Hall 2007)

Treatment of breathlessness is specially problematic. Corresponding to Knower et al. it is because the symptomatology is both varied and multifactorial. It is not simply a matter of too little tidal level in the lungs, it is a multisystem disorder numerous possible subtle neurohormonal abnormalities and interactions in skeletal and breathing muscle composition and function. In addition, the experience is incredibly subjective with the sensation of breathlessness being altered by not only past experience of the symptom but also by pathways from a number of different areas within the central nervous system.

Dorman et al. classify malignancy-associated breathlessness into four communities by their different causative mechanisms.

An increase in the sense of respiratory drive or effort to get over an imposed insert (e. g. long-term obstructive pulmonary disease, COPD)

An increase in the percentage of available respiratory muscle force necessary for breathing, observed in neuromuscular weakness where respiratory motor end result and the sense of work increase (e. g. paraneoplastic syndromes)

An upsurge in the patient's ventilatory requirements (e. g. anaemia, hypoxaemia)

The contribution of higher cortical experience to the sensation. Memory and prior experience as well as anxiety and stress will all adjust the feeling of breathlessness.

(Dorman, Jolley, Abernethy, Currow et al. 2009)

The evidence platform for treatment demonstrates one effective mechanism is to treatment any underlying additive cause, such as anaemia, hypoxia or bronchospasm. (Hatley, Laurence, Scott & Thomas 2008)

If one considers the physical elements first, one common factor in the knowledge of breathlessness in every these situations is anxiety. One common effective strategy to reduce the subjective sensation is designed for the patient to learn rest and calm respiration techniques and then to consciously use them every time they feel anxious and breathless.

Oxygen therapy is generally useful in reducing the symptoms of breathlessness and the occurrence of a nose catheter or cover up is often reassuring for the individual. The main evidence basic for symptomatic control however, originates from the utilization of the opioid and benzodiazepine group of medications.

Opiates have definitely the strongest research base with the evidence level Ib newspaper by Pharo et al. evidently demonstrating the reduced amount of both subjective and objective measurements of breathlessness in patients with lung cancers. (Pharo & Zhou 2005). The writers point out that the side effects of opiates, as a course, must be carefully weighed against their probable medical benefits. Careful study of the evidence platform encouraging benzodiazepine use demonstrates it is less secure. Some creators (viz. Wotton 2004) confirming that they have reduced the sensation of dyspnoea in patients, nearly all randomised controlled studies (viz. Maher, Selecky, Harrod & Benditt 2010, ) havent been able to demonstrate any convincing advantage whilst demonstrating significant side results. They are also known to decrease respiratory drive and compromise lung function, worsening exercise tolerance. ( Franco-Bronson 2006). On balance, the evidence base will not support the use of the benzodiazepine group for the comfort of breathlessness in malignant disease.

Anxiety and depressive disorder, both common associations of malignant disease, are commonly associated with increased perceptions of breathlessness. There's a substantial evidence basic showing that aggressive treatment of both can produce significant improvement in subjective assessments of the symptom. Treatment of these conditions are complex and specialised and for that reason will never be considered in detail. Kunik et al. have shown in an data level IIa study that both anxiolytics (buspirone ) and mental health relaxation techniques are capable of producing significant decreases in levels of both stress and anxiety and dyspnoea, as well as improved exercise tolerance among breathless patients. (Kunik, Azzam, Souchek, Cully, Wray, Krishnan, et al. 2007)

In the passions of providing a comprehensive and balanced discussion, note should be studied of the recent proof level IIa paper by Lewith et al. which noted the positive, however, not statistically significant aftereffect of acupuncture on patients suffering from breathlessness. It will also be mentioned these were patients with breathlessness as an 'all-cause' sign somewhat than specifically from malignant disease. (Lewith, Prescott & Davis 2006)

The evidence bottom part associated with treatment of coughing, a common indication in lung malignancy. It really is generally taken up to indicate engagement of the airways as opposed to the lung parenchyma, generally due to location of coughing receptors.

Kvale published an especially helpful Medline review in 2008 which explored the evidence base for treatment options. (Kvale 2008). The paper itself is both considerable and extensive. Confining the debate to the relevant helpings of the paper implies that both surgery and radiotherapy (where appropriate) are both effective in minimizing troublesome coughing symptoms. A patient having chemotherapy is less likely to have their coughing symptoms reduced.

There is a considerable evidence base to aid the view that the utilization of inhaled bronchodilators and corticosteroids can be useful, but not in every cases.

Specific antitussive centrally performing drugs that contain been subjected to randomised controlled tests include codeine, hydrocodone, and dextromethorphan. Each of these has a strong supporting evidence base and minimum part results. Dihydrocodeine has been specifically noted as getting the dual reason for both pain relief and coughing suppression. (Homsi, Walsh, & Nelson 2001). The opiate group generally, in addition to relieving pain and breathlessness are also firmly active in coughing suppression.

The creators make the point that many tests have noted the cough suppression effect of placebos in randomised managed trials. This has not only the result of adding an aspect of bias into the results, but offers a line in general management of coughing in resistant conditions.

Fatigue is a common warning sign associated with malignancies and certainly with lung cancers. This latter relationship is postulated to be related to the degrees of chronic hypoxia in the later phases of the condition. (Higginson, McCarthy 2008)

The Dagnelie et al. analysis is particularly useful in this respect as it considered the effect of exhaustion on the grade of life of patients with lung cancers and discovered that it includes clear statistical organizations with the level of the disease process, the degree of support that the patient has and also the mental state of the individual. (Dagnelie, Pijls-Johannesn, Lambin & Beijer 2007). They discovered that those patients who acquired good support networks, and who were not depressed and who could actually maintain a good degree of physical exercise were the ones who were least likely to report significant degrees of exhaustion. A substantive literature search has didn't reveal worthwhile quality studies which support these studies from a restorative perspective but intuitively, one might claim that including the maintenance of a support network and immediate diagnosis for depressive symptoms into a alternative management plan will probably reduce degrees of tiredness experienced by the individual.

In passing, you can consider the recent Breitbart analysis which viewed the use of psycho stimulants in circumstances of malignancy-related fatigue and found encouraging results from Modafinil, which really is a new category of psychostimulant commonly referred to as wakefulness-promoting agent in the literature. It looks well tolerated and with few side results. The email address details are too not used to have yet been replicated with a more substantial randomised managed trial and the authors also indicate a large possible placebo result in their trial. In these situations, the evidence platform should perhaps be considered 'unproven' until further proof emerges. (Breitbart & Alici 2010)

The research study makes reference to passing reference to Andrew, Claire's partner, who retired 2 yrs ago and is also clearly the main carer in this scenario. He does the shopping, baking and different other domestic duties for Clare. Although our company is told that makes him feel 'useful' the experienced and empathetic doctor should be aware that the levels of occult melancholy in cancer-afflicted patient's spouses is incredibly high. (Kim, Duberstein, Sorensen & Larson 2005)

It has commonly been found to be the circumstance that as the focus of good care and intervention is normally targeted towards the patient, the carers, and specially the spouses, don't have their needs either explored, considered or addressed. (Braun, Mikulincer, Rydall, Walsh & Rodin 2007)

It is part of the holistic diagnosis of the patient's situation that the carers should be actively considered and been able as actively as the individual. It has the direct effect not only of aiming to optimise the entire levels of care for the individual, but also promoting the spoken exchange of information, thoughts and feelings which are extremely likely never to be addressed of recognised, if not explicitly facilitated. (Kim, Schulz & Carver 2007)

The evidence basic for these interventions is not strong. There's a considerable evidence bottom, from a big quantity of qualitative studies, which underlines the actual fact that spouses and carers, if recognized, can improve the standard of living for the patient. It also appears to be the situation that spiritual health of the individual is improved if spouses and carers are inspired and facilitated to speak about the situation, especially impending loss of life, which is often seen as a 'taboo' subject in a household with a patient with a malignancy. Qualitative studies certainly fortify the evidence platform, but, in terms of recommendations and management strategies, they are generally not seen as being as strong as quantitative studies. (Gomm & Davies 2008)

In conclusion, the evidence foundation to devise a management strategy for Claire is dependent generally on the mechanisms used to identify her symptom foundation as well as her circumstances. It seems likely that Claire is adapting to her health problems trajectory with at the least cognitive distortion, and is taking a rather fatalistic view of her situation. Management should evidently be mainly supportive, both of her and her partner. The evidence basic for symptom control is rather strong. Pain is not a feature at the moment. Breathlessness could be tackled, primarily by the instigation of anxiety-relieving behaviours and possibly by small dosages of opiods. Cough can be helped through dihydrocodeine if it is troublesome and fatigue needs careful analysis to ascertain whether there may be any depressive or mental health factors which are either major of additive to the symptomatology.

Claire may also have to be 'given authorization' to rest during the day and be informed to schedule herself with physical exercise so that her tiredness is not such an issue on her behalf.

Healthcare professionals need to consider their interventions with the family meticulously. Claire perceives that they 'come from the woodwork', which suggests that they are an unwelcome reminder to the fact that they are just there because she has a serious and ultimately terminal condition. Claire might need to be encouraged to talk and expand upon this issue as the family could find it difficult if they are not welcomed, and Claire may need to be helped to confront the truth of her situation more straight.

Andrew must not be overlooked when building a management technique for this situation. It really is a standard finding for professional medical professionals to understand that the spouse is 'being strong', but this can be a faade because of their partner. It is a useful technique for the doctor to make time to talk to Andrew by himself so that he can hold the opportunity to raise issues that he might be unclear about. It may be that he will not know what to expect and is uncertain of the greatest way of managing the situation. Although possibly early at this time, part of the management plan ought to be to discuss how Andrew is going to plan a worsening situation.

An essay such as this can only realistically consider the problem from a general approach. It is clearly the case that each strategy and involvement is highly recommended on the basis of a holstic examination of the average person and the management tailored directly to the specific circumstances of the average person.

Appendix I

Classification of proof levels


Evidence from meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.


Evidence obtained from at least one randomised managed trial.


Evidence from at least one well-designed managed study without randomisation.


Evidence extracted from at least an added type of well-designed quasi-experimental research.


Evidence extracted from well-designed non-experimental descriptive studies, such as comparative studies, correlation studies and circumstance studies.


Evidence obtained from expert committee reviews or viewpoints and/or clinical experience of respected regulators.

(SIGN 2001)

Appendix II

Case Details

Clare's doctor has just referred her to the city palliative attention service. Clare is a 65 12 months old girl, with lung malignancy, an eventually fatal condition. She lives with her partner Andrew in their house. Her two increased children are married and live interstate.

Clare suffers from breathlessness, cough and tiredness. She gets distressed by her incapability to 'get her breathing'. Sometimes she has trouble sleeping at night and is frequently sleepy during the day. Clare says she doesn't have many ways of help her control her symptoms. She views her disease as difficult as it impacts on what she can do and she doesn't feel in charge of her life.

Clare tells you that personal human relationships are more significant on her behalf now and she misses finding her children, even though she maintains in frequent phone contact. She actually is surprised by the number of people who've 'come from the woodwork' and have come to visit her at home.

Andrew retired two years ago so can do the shopping, cooking food and other home responsibilities for him and Clare. He says this makes him feel 'useful' and it's easier for him to do things than to talk about things. Andrew asks you if there is anything more he can do to help Clare.

More than 7 000 students trust us to do their work
90% of customers place more than 5 orders with us
Special price $5 /page
Check the price
for your assignment