Studybay uses cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. By continuing to use Studybay you accept our use of cookies view more on our Cookie Policy

Modernization Theory and Dependence Theory Analysis

In this day and age the speedy development of the term and the growing assimilation of countries can hardly fail to have an effect on the development of new ideas which try to explain the partnership between countries and the prevailing inequality between developed countries and countries of the 3rd world. Two theories which review the development in under-developed countries will be the modernization theory and the dependence theory. Both of these ideas, while being somewhat different, still have several similarities in their views on the modern world and romantic relationships between developed and expanding countries.

As Alvin So described, there are three key and historical basics which were constructive to the foundation of the modernization theory of development following the Second World War. First, america rose as a superpower. While other Traditional western countries, such as Great Britain, France, and Germany, were undermined by World War II, america came out of the warfare more robust then before, and became a world leader with the execution of the Marshall Intend to reconstruct Western European countries. [2]Second, the thought of communist began to move across the world. What was after the Soviet Union pass on its influence to Eastern Europe, China, and Korea. Third, there is the breakdown ofEuropean colonial empires in Asia, Africa and Latin America, creating numerous new nation-states in the Third World. These budding nation-states commenced searching for a form of development to support their economy also to improve their political self-reliance. The modernization theory's intellectual lineage has been followed back to Aristotle. Aristotle first recommended that states, equally as plants, experienced a natural routine of growth. Exactly like Aristotle, Us citizens in the first Republic assumed that if societies increase in an all natural manner, they must also perish. The idea that the progression of real human development could be known and controlled times to the early nineteenth century, when France and Britain were attempting to bring back their trade empires. Since then it offers tended to reappear sometimes and places where systems of dominance required explanation and rationalization.

The modernization theory talks about the internal factors of the country with the assumption that, with help, "traditional" countries can be developed in the same way more developed countries have. The modernization theory attempts to identify the social variables which cause sociable expansion and development of societies, and then will try to make clear the social progression. In order for a country to truly have a profitable, advanced, modern economy the united states are required to follow a style of development. That is a very organized theory as it means do one thing and another may happen. In order for this to occur, there have to be prerequisites for takeoff that will lead to takeoff where will lead to mass-consumption(Mahler 45). A lacking component of this theory is usually that the modernization theory assumes all countries will observe the set path to development. There are numerous variables where will influence a claims' potential to in fact develop. A good example of this is actually the undeniable fact that Mexico is geographically designed in a way that will cause it to truly have a weak economy because of the deserts, forests, and mountains. This makes it so that only 12% of the land is arable. The actual fact that we now have no major streams doesn't help either. These issues all help making it challenging for Mexico to develop since it restrains transportation, which weakens the probability of exporting and importing goods in a efficient manner. Another problem with the modernization theory is that it assumes that states have the necessary preconditions to build up. This isn't true as much states do not have proper market leaders and government. The real reason for this is that if a state is manipulated by weak authority, it will in turn influence its potential to develop. For example, Saddam Hussein, managed to get so that his country could not develop because he needed every one of the prosperity for himself. Perhaps, if Hussein got spread the riches throughout his country, this will have helped education and increased technology. This could have managed to get so that his country developed in a far more useful manner.

One coverage implication the modernization theory implies is that the third world countries should research to the developed traditional western nations, as the Western countries should spread more modern worth, establishments, technology, and financial investment to the 3rd World countries. Another implication is that for the third worlds to build up, they should be moving along the path that the United States has journeyed, hence move from the ideas of communism. (READING)

A theory in which is against the Modernization model which was created essentially as a reply to it's the Dependency theory. Dependency theories developed in opposition to the optimistic says of modernizationtheory which observed the less developed countries being able to meet up with the Western world. They pressured that Traditional western societies had a pastime in maintaining their advantaged position with regards to the LDCs and got the financial and complex wherewithal to do so. A number of different accounts of the relationship between the advanced and less developed says developed within the wide platform of dependency theory, ranging from the stagnationism and 'surplus drain' theory of Andre Gunder Frank (which predicted erroneously that the 3rd World would be unable to achieve significant levels ofindustrialization), to a lot more cautious pessimism of these who envisaged a measure of growth predicated on 'associated based mostly' relationships with the Western world.

The major contribution to dependency theory was absolutely that of Frank, a German economist of development who devised and popularized the phrase 'the development of underdevelopment', talking about what he noticed as the deformed and based mostly economies of the peripheral states-in his terminology the 'satellites' of the more complex 'metropolises'. InCapitalism and Underdevelopment in Latin America(1969), he argued that the Third World was doomed to stagnation because the surplus it produced was appropriated by the advanced capitalist countries, through organizations such as transnational companies. Frank himself insisted that progress could only be achieved by severing ties with capitalism and seeking autocentric socialist development strategies.

According to the dependency theory, the Global North exploits the Global South. One reason behind this would be that the south is highly reliant on the prosperity of the north; therefore struggling to advance themselves because of the vicious pattern that then ensues. An example of this vicious pattern can begin with a country being inadequate and/or economically unstable. They then allow a multinational firm to create camp in another of their metropolitan areas. This leads to many new jobs for this city, however the people are hired for inadequate wages. Then the products that are produced get siphoned off by the Global North, in turn preventing that says "mass-consumption" abilities which really is a generalized way that the south gets exploited by the north and the multinational company comes out making huge profits at the expense of anxious people just seeking to survive and eager to benefit pennies.

The depencde theory has several implications. First, Campaign of local industry and made goods. By imposing subsidies to safeguard domestic companies, poor countries can be empowered to sell their own products somewhat than exporting recycleables. Second, Import limitations. By restricting the importation ofluxury goodsandmanufactured goodsthat can be produced within the united states, the united states can reduce its lack of capital and resources. Thrid, Forbidding overseas investment. Some governments had taken steps to keep foreign companies and people from owning or operating property that draws on the sources of the united states.

In bottom line, both theories confess the leadership of american countries and their presently prominent position in today's world, while undeveloped countries are seen as a socio-economic and political backwardness. At the same time, the two ideas concur that the cooperation between western countries and developing countries is continually growing and leads to their integration. However, it's important to underline that Modernization theory views such cooperation and integration as a conscious and voluntary act from the part of producing countries, for which modernization in the traditional western style is the only way to overcome the prevailing backwardness, while supporters of Dependency theory dispute that such co-operation and integration is enforced to developing countries by more complex traditional western countries, which simply attempt to benefit from their cooperation with producing countries and their westernization becomes a means of the establishment of control over and growing dependence of expanding countries on developed ones. Irrespective, the existing dissimilarities, both ideas still raise a very important problem of romantic relationships between developed and expanding countries and the dominance of european countries and european civilization in today's world.

  • More than 7,000 students prefer us to work on their projects
  • 90% of customers trust us with more than 5 assignments
submit a project

Latest posts

Read more informative topics on our blog
The Educational Curriculum INSIDE THE Philippines Education Essay
Education The educational curriculum in the Philippines is low in comparison to other countries. Other countries are able to find out more advanced...
The Ecotourism In Scotland Travel and leisure Essay
Tourism Hospitality and travel and leisure are very closely linked; every time a tourist comes to Scotland there are lots of restaurant and hotels to...
Corporate Social Responsibility: Targets and Concepts
Business Abstract Corporate Social Responsibility is a management principle whereby companies integrate social and environmental concerns in their...
A Personal Reflection AROUND THE ITM Information Technology Essay
Information Technology I have been in information technology industry for a long time. I have first-hand information technology experience especially in...
The Theory Of Mcdonaldization Commerce Essay
Commerce McDonaldization is the process where the concepts of the junk food industry have come to dominate an increasing variety of organizations in...
The Interpretation Of Life Quotes
Philosophy As you all know most of us are here in this planet for a while only and our life or being blessed as a individuals is a gift irrespective of...
The Sex Appeal In Advertising Mass media Essay
Media Through the years we have found a diversity advertising resources for offering products which were calling the attention of the costumers, to be...
Impacts of Tourism Deregulation and National Security
Marketing National security is definitely an issue going out with back to as early as when man started out arranging himself in contemporary society....
Homogeneous And Differentiated Product In Microeconomics Economics Essay
Economics The economic issue in this observation involves the concept of homogeneous and differentiated product in microeconomics According to Lindeman...
Check the price
for your project
we accept
Money back
100% quality
Plagiarism free writing service