Importance of learning how to write a critique paper



Reading time

7 minutes

Importance of learning how to write a critique paper

Although the term criticize has a negative connotation, writing a critique of any object, text, experience or place entails looking at all component parts and providing judgment. You have to make your readers understand why and how you arrived at your judgment and a properly written critique gives the readers an understanding of the values of the critic. In order to understand how to write a critique paper you first need to understand the aim of writing a critique paper. Critique paper writing is something more than just providing a summary of an article. It entails evaluation, analysis and interpretation of the writing. A critique paper provides information about the main concept of the article being critiqued, its intended audience, the author’s objective and attitude towards the presented ideas. Additionally, to write a perfect critique you must identify any biases on the author’s part. Moreover, a critique is meant to investigate how the article is structured, determine whether the ideas or information is presented in a coherent manner and that it provides an opinion about credibility and importance of the information that the author has presented.

Having enough knowledge on how to write a critique paper is very important for many reasons. First, various people perform their researches based on a previous research. So you should be able to analyze and interpret what was established before. This can be done through empirical evidence or development of theory. This simply means that you have to examine the reliability and validity of what other people have proposed through theory building or evidence. You should also be able to determine how the thoughts, findings and conclusions of the other people are related to one’s research opinions. It is also very important to be able to summarize the reports offered accurately since they relate to one’s discoveries.

Writing a critique

After understanding the importance of knowing how to write a critique paper, you also need to understand how to write the actual critique paper. To write a critique paper you first need to know what you are required to critique. You cannot critique something that you do not understand. Study the material that you are required to critique very carefully and understand the overall argument of the author. You can read through the material several times in order to determine the author’s purpose in the argument, the intended audience and whether the work effectively reaches this audience. Also, find out if the author has valid evidence. While reading, it is very important to take notes. These notes will be very useful when you will be writing the actual critique.

You have to understand the intended audience, the subject matter of the article and its importance to the expected readers. And take note of your reactions after reading the work, whether you feel confused or you are contented and if there are any questions that have been left unanswered. The next step in writing a critique paper is to perform a little research. In order for you to write an excellent critique, you require some background information on the field of the subject of that work. Research thoroughly and use your research findings, your knowledge and your education opinion to disagree or agree to the author’s work. For example, if you are required to critique a research paper on the cure for a certain disease, you have to know more about the disease and other cure researches that have been done before or are ongoing. This helps you to determine the strengths and weaknesses of the work that you are critiquing. With good background knowledge, you will be able to write a perfect critique paper. You must provide an empirical argument to defend your stance and while there is no such thing as a lot of good evidence, over searching can be a problem as well if your arguments become redundant. So ensure that every source of your research contains something that is unique for your critique. In addition, do not let your research sources to crowd out your arguments and opinions.

When writing a critique paper, bear in mind that a critique varies depending on the task and the discipline and that it does not need to be entirely negative or entirely positive. In fact, a literary critique is more interesting when you not only disagree with an author but also when you build the author’s idea with additional evidence. But in case you agree with the author entirely, ensure that you build on the argument by giving additional evidence to the author’s idea. You can as well give contradictory evidence to the argument while still maintaining that a certain idea is the right one. Writing a critique is like writing a literature review. At times, it can be a complete journal article that is based on an assessment of the current literature and at times, it is a chapter in a thesis. Sometimes you may be provided a selection of articles for you to appraise in order to come up with a review and critique of that particular topic. Regardless of the task, in all critiques you are required to integrate the broader literature.

Format of a critique paper

The first section of a critique paper is the introduction. In a critique introduction, you introduce the work that you are critiquing. It should not be more than two paragraphs and must lay out the framework of your critique. You can begin an introduction by writing down where the work in question fails or succeeds and give reasons to support your opinion.

When writing an introduction, you assume that your audience has not come across this type of work before and that the readers of your critique do not know the author of the work either. It should contain the author’s name, the title of the work and the statement given by the author. You may include the date when the work was done and mention your reaction to the content of that work. You will state the work’s context and this critique section should end with a thesis statement. A thesis statement is a sentence that summarizes your evaluation of the work. It can be positive, negative or mixed. The second section in writing a critique paper is the summary. A summary provides an overview of the main ideas of the author. The main points that you will pick are the ones that will form the basis of your critique. That is what you will criticize in this section while ensuring that you mention all the major points. Note that you might be tempted to state your ideas of interest in the critique. That is not professional and it is not allowed. Your critique must be honest and fair.

The third section of a critique paper is the body. This is the critique itself. There are no strict rules for the number of paragraphs when it comes to writing a critique paper body. The length of your critique depends on the nature of the work that you are critiquing. A critique of a novel for example consists of a minimum of two paragraphs, whereby one paragraph is for the book’s summary and the other paragraph is for the book’s evaluation. Your critique should be a comprehensive assessment of the work that you are critiquing. It should not be inclined to negative opinions only but should address both the failures and the achievements of the author. Some of the things you need to consider in this section include: determining whether the objectives of the work was achieved and whether there were any assumptions that were made by the author and how those assumptions affect the effectiveness of the work.

To come up with a creative critique, you need to state the techniques and styles used by the author and explain how they assist in attaining the goal of the work. If you are critiquing a media item or a research paper, you will need to assess the data collection techniques that were used. Analyze the author’s claims and determine if they are well supported and if there is enough evidence for those claims. The body of the critique varies depending on the type of work being evaluated. The various types of works can include a song, a film, a research paper, an article, and so on. Your evaluation should contain examples from the work you are critiquing in order to support your judgment. You can also include evidence from external sources and cite them accordingly.

The last section of a critique paper is the conclusion. A critique paper conclusion should be concise, indicating your overall evaluation and the reasons for your final judgment. You must include both negative and positive critiques in your conclusion. Evaluate the value of the work for readers and compare it to some other works of the same field. Mention if that work is worth reading and give reasons why. Mention what the reader and you, in particular, can learn from that work, and whether you can recommend that work to others and why. Mention if you agree with the author and in case you disagree, explain why. Provide your general opinion of the work and try to be specific by giving concrete examples. In this section, you can also make recommendations for improvement to the author of the work. After writing the conclusion paragraph, you should add a list of references for all sources that you used in the critique and ensure that your critique paper has correct citations.

Originally published Jul 04, 2017, updated Dec 30, 2020

Confusing homework?

Get expert help in any course or subject

Get Help