Essay on A Promising Solution Comes From The Argument Of Misfortune

A good solution comes from the disagreement of bad luck. (Benn, 1967) Here, the

morally relevant variation between animals and humans is the counter-factual quality of

misfortune. This suggested quality of misfortune communicates the meaning significance about what could have

been the case rather than what is the case. Instead of focusing on a human's potential to develop

enhanced moral capabilities in the foreseeable future, this disagreement focuses on what a human could have

probably developed if they had not endured a misfortune.

According for this argument, the key reason why we would experiment on a usual dog rather than a

cognitively disabled individual is that although the human has suffered a bad luck, the dog hasn't.

(Kaufman, 1998, g. 155) Like a person is the norm for any human being. In the event the human hadn't suffered

the bad luck of having a severe human brain impairment, he would have developed each of the cognitive

capacities needed to obtain the meaning significance of a person. In comparison, the dog has not suffered

a misfortune since it can be regular for his species to acquire limited intellectual capacities. Therefore, we

should choose to experiment in animals since this will not be taking advantage of a bad luck whereas

experimenting about cognitively-disabled human beings will be.

This argument allows us to overcome the barrier of making use of actual cognitive capacities and grants

the hobbies of cognitively-disabled humans' higher moral value than pets or animals for

experimentation. Therefore we could subject to Singer's claim by citing meaningful cognitive capabilities

and the morally-relevant component of bad luck to allow equally cognitively-abled and cognitively-

incapable humans into our principle of equal rights but not family pets.

One counter-argument Singer give...

... involving the cognitively-disabled human beings and the pets or animals.

In conclusion, I've demonstrated that Vocalist is right in claiming all of us cannot morally treat

comparable interests from animals and humans as different. We cannot work with actual capabilities to find

a morally-relevant element which grants humans increased moral thought than individuals

(beyond staying sentient) since this always causes the exemption of brain-damaged humans.

Using the even more promising counter-factual quality of misfortune does not overcome this

unsavoury implication mainly because it also offers an unclear variation between pets and cognitively-

disabled humans. This means Musician is right in saying we should either acknowledge animals in the

rule of similar consideration of interests, or perhaps allow cognitively-disabled individuals to endure the

same burden as family pets in being used for painful tests.

  • More than 7,000 students prefer us to work on their projects
  • 90% of customers trust us with more than 5 assignments
Special
price
$5
/page
submit a project

Latest posts

Read more informative topics on our blog
Essay upon Autism Range Disorder Surgery
behavior remedy, symptoms, treatment - Autism Spectrum Disorder Interventions
Graduation Talk: Mom and Dad, Your Babies Have Grown Up!
Category: Graduation Talk, Commencement Talk about; Title: Graduating Speech: Mom and Dad, Your Infants Have Grown Up!
Essay about Perceval
essays research papers - Perceval
Essay in Abortion Is usually Murder
Argumentative Essay, Pro-life - Illigal baby killing Is Tough
Prison Overcrowding Is A Major Concern Article
Criminal proper rights, Prison, Criminal offense, House arrest - Jail Overcrowding Is known as a Major Matter
Emily Bronte Essay
Literary works - Emily Bronte
Dog Farm
Category: Book Review Brief summary Analysis; Subject: Animal Farm
Wolf Reintroductions Essay
Environmental, Endangered Species, Yellowstone - Wolf Reintroductions
Essay about Characteristics that Accompany Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
Paperwork - Characteristics that Accompany Fetal Alcohol Syndrome
Check the price
for your project
we accept
Money back
guarantee
100% quality
Plagiarism free writing service