We accept

Contrast Of Roy And Orems Nursing Theory Nursing Essay

Nursing is an evolving self-control in the introduction of research i. e. theory and research and in professional practice. We have a rich record of thought from Florence Nightingale to the recent nurse researchers, theorists and clinicians. Furthermore, nursing professional practice includes integration of knowledge from the extensive conceptualizations of models to the level of practice theory. The nursing theoretical frameworks serve in powerful ways as courses for articulating, confirming, recording medical thought and action. Nurses must know what these are doing, why they can be doing, what may be the range of final results of medical, and indications for measuring medical impact (Parker, 2001). The aim of this paper is to review, compare and contrast two nursing models given by two nursing theorists who've made major efforts in the field of nursing practice. These models are; Roy adaptation model and Orem's Self-care model.

Introduction to the theorists, Sister Callista Roy and Dorothea E. Orem

Sister Callista Roy received a bachelor's degree in nursing in 1963 from Mount Saint Mary's University as master's level in pediatric medical in 1966, a master's degree in sociology in 1975 and a doctorate degree in sociology in 1977, all from the College or university of California, LA. Roy first suggested her model while learning on her behalf master's level, where she was challenged by Dorothy Johnson to build up conceptual models of nursing. Therefore, the introduction of the version model for nursing has been inspired by Roy's personal and professional record. She possessed her experience as a pediatric personnel nurse where she mainly noticed the children and their capacity to adjust in response to major physical and internal changes.

Dorothea E. Orem was born in Baltimore, Maryland. She received her diploma in nursing from Providence Medical center School of Medical in Washington, DC, baccalaureate in medical from Catholic School in 1939 and master's level in 1945 from the same university. She made a decision to develop her theory after she and her colleagues were given an assignment to produce a nursing curricula for useful nursing for the division of Health, Education and Welfare in Washington, DC. Between 1971 and the 1995 editions, there have been some changes in Orem's theory, notably in the idea of a person and the thought of the medical system. Orem delineates three theories; self-care, self-care deficit, and nursing system.

Focus of Roy's and Orem's Model

Roy's model was at first developed for education; however, it continued to work in research and practice configurations. Roy's model targets the concept of adaptation of man. Her principles of nursing, person, health insurance and environment are all interrelated to this central concept. Corresponding to her model, the individual receives inputs or stimuli from both the environment and the do it yourself. Adaptation occurs when the individual responds positively to environmental changes. This adaptive response encourages the integrity of the individual which brings about health. Ineffective replies to stimuli lead to disruption of the integrity of the individual.

Self-care model was presented with by Dorothea Elizabeth Orem in 1970. The concentration of the model is self-care, self-care firm, self-care demand, self-care deficit, nursing organization and nursing system. Self-care is a dependence on everyone, man, woman and child. Self-care can be regarded as function and the capability of an individual meaning the things an individual can do and able to do. When self-care is not maintained, health problems, disease or death will arise. Self-care requisites lead to the rules of structural and functional integrity and human being development. You can find three categories of self-care requisites; general, developmental and health deviation self-care requisites. Corresponding to Orem, there are numerous basic conditioning factors (get older, gender, developmental status, health talk about and health care system, sociocultural orientation, and family system, habits of living, environment and available resources) that can effect the categories of self-care requisites. The essence of Orem's model is completely the nurse-patient romantic relationship.

Metaparadigm of both the Models

The Person:

Roy described the individual in terms of system and adaptation, a biopsychosocial being in continuous conversation with a changing environment. She defines person as a recipient of nursing care, as a full time income organic, adaptive system with inner operations (the cognator and regulator) performing to maintain version in the four adaptive modes: physiological (biologic), self-concept (psychological), role function and interdependence (interpersonal). The cognator control buttons functions related to belief, learning, common sense, and feelings i. e. subconscious changes. The regulator functions mostly by using the autonomic stressed system to make physiologic modifications.

On the other palm, Orem indicated that the individual person is the primary concentrate in the model. Folks are basically logical beings who evaluate situations, represent and understand them. Based on this person as agent or having company that chooses to perform specific activities and goal aimed. Moreover, compared to Roy's model, she also suggested that empowering person helps to cope with the complexities and effects which ultimately progress to the positive adaptation of an individual.


Roy's goal of medical is to help specific adapt to changes in his subconscious needs, self-concept, role function and interdependent relations during health and disorder. Nursing fills a distinctive role as a facilitator of adaptation by assessing patterns in each of these four adaptive methods and intervening by taking care of the influencing stimuli (George, 1995).

Similarly, Orem defines medical as a real human service and facilitates that medical special concern is a person's physiological needs for the provision and management of self-care action on a continuing basis in order to support life and health. However, the goal of nursing in both the ideas is to beat the patient's limitation whether it is internal or physiological needs.


According to Roy and Andrews (1999) health is circumstances and process of being and becoming a and entire person. In the same way Orem (1985) considers health as an ideal when living things are structurally and functionally complete. Health may very well be a individual adaptive system within the changing environment. Insufficient integration represents lack of health. Version is a process of promoting this integration i. e. keeping physiological, internal and public integrity. Similarly, corresponding to Horsburgh (1999), Orem views health condition as the essential fitness factor also comprises on physiological, mental health and public imbalances probably to impact adult self-care capabilities and behaviours.


According to Roy (1999), environment is all the conditions, circumstances that affects surrounding and affect the development and action of persons or groupings. Environment is the insight into the person as an adaptive system relating both interior and external factors. Any environmental change requirements increasing energy to adjust to the problem. Factors in the surroundings that affect the person are classified as focal, contextual and residual stimuli. Focal stimulus largely confronts the individual that precipitates the habit. Contextual stimuli are other stimuli present that contribute to the behavior induced or precipitated by the focal stimuli. Residual stimuli are factors which may be affecting behavior but whose impacts aren't validated.

Orem acknowledges self-care requisites to acquire their origins in humans and the environmental factors, elements, conditions, etc. Environmental factors influences health care abilities of any person and are formed within someone's sociocultural context. Furthermore, she suggested the similar concept of Roy's theory that man and environment interact as self-care system. If the system of man and environment gets change, the version of self-care system will be affected.

Identification of the main assumptions is necessary to inside and external analysis of the theory which deals with logic, consistency and congruence with the practical world (Barnum, 1998). The concept of person, health, nursing and environment are well described however there are a few similarities and variations among the two models. Firstly, Roy's model concentrates mainly on mental aspects of a person. She discusses about the version of a guy and stresses on ways of adaptation and coping mechanisms whereas Orem's model centers greatly on physiological and sociological areas of a person and lacks mental health aspects. She talks about individualism, autonomy, self-directed and self-reliance. Moustafa (1999) also mentioned that Orem's theory is generally accorded to the physiological and sociological wellbeing of the person, undermining the value of mental health. For e. g. , somebody who is a paranoid schizophrenic won't declare that he needs help regarding his self-care demands and without approval of the self-care deficit, it'll be difficult to look after the person using Orem's theory concepts.

Secondly, corresponding to Roy (1999) environment is inner and exterior stimuli and the individual will get inputs from the external and internal conditions. In her prior writing (1981) that environment differs from inner stimuli and now she viewed inner stimuli is an integral part of environment. However, the question develops if inside stimuli are a part of environment than how it differs from the individuals adaptation level? In addition, Roy's model of nursing management identify that the manipulation of the stimuli is different from the manipulation of men and women however the question still remains the same can internal stimuli be manipulated without manipulating the person? It appears that the connections of adaptation to person, health insurance and nursing are obvious nevertheless the person-environment discussion is less clear. On the other hand, Orem simply suggested that the change in person-environment system will finally change the whole self-care system. Both the models showcase similar factors but the objective of both theorists differ as in case of Orem, it is self-care whereas Roy as version. Nevertheless, both models can be interrelated for e. g. , to be able to perform self-care efficiently, a person needs to adapt to the inner and external stimuli or the environment. The person needs to be stress free and comfortable both actually and psychologically. Both version and self-care is a behavior of somebody who are inspired by various factors such as culture, personality, socioeconomic position, education, years, gender and available resources etc.

Thirdly, both these models primarily give attention to individualism. Do not require takes the point of view of family, society, or a community all together. However, with certain adjustment, the models have emerged empirically analyzed on various age ranges such as among student's community, elderly, various disease specific organizations etc. Roy recognizes person as a full time income complicated, adaptive system acting to maintain version in four adaptive models (physiological needs, self-concept, role function and interdependence) whereas relating to Orem, person as rational beings who has mastery over their destiny. In other words, the individual as one is independent to choose and select whatever they want. It really is normal for the person who would like to attain optimum degrees of self-care. However, this is not true at on a regular basis; a person buying secondary gain from the illness may well not give importance to his/her health and fitness. Regarding health, both of these assume that health is a state and a process for becoming a and entire person. However, these models lack the spiritual and existentialist areas of a person. These models summarize nurse as a facilitator. The purpose of the nurse in Roy's model is to help man adjust to changes brought about through the health health problems continuum whereas matching to Orem's model, nurse facilitates the self-care abilities of an person which is more to the physiological needs of a person.

Lastly, Orem's model is somehow culturally biased. In medically advance culture, people think that sickness is due to natural reason. However, some civilizations consider on traditional and folk premises. Therefore, these perceptions remain failing to recognize all of the health related cultural belief and techniques. Orem's theory does not explain the original and folk health feels even she called a clinically advanced culture (Orem, 1991). On the other hand, Roy's model discusses the person's marriage with the entire world and God on philosophical premises. Individuals use real human creative skills of awareness, enlightenment and beliefs. In my view I feel that as an exterior stimuli or factor, ethnic and spiritual believes can hinder in version process.

Furthermore, both theories are incredibly complex and also have broad ideas for the sensible implication. Roy's model is difficult to categorize the actions of the individual in the four adaptive modes (George, 1995). In addition, there can be an overlapping of ideas definitions. Likewise, Orem's self-care model can be used with numerous configurations; this large number of terms such as self-care organization, self-care demand, self-care deficit, requisites can be very perplexing to the audience. Abdul (2002) also mentioned that Orem's work is easy to describe but difficult to differentiate among numerous terminologies and hypothesis. The holistic approach of the models aids in preventing adding too much focus on aspects of disorder and permits the inclusion of health promotion. In addition, they are really easy to apply as a family centre model. Both have been found very helpful in inpatient and outpatient configurations as well as in work configurations and in the community. However, it is difficult to apply Roy's model in intense care devices where situations change quickly (George, 1995). Moreover, the professional medical research generating from these theories have health advertising application also. Nursing, when define in conditions of focus ( for knowledge and practice), is a professional health service necessitated by an individuals inability to keep the amount and quality of self-care i. e. therapeutic in sustaining life and health, even in recovering from disease or personal injury, or in coping with their results through version.

Roy's advertising Orem's model have greatly affected nursing occupation. The integration of both the models is not only applicable in specialized medical practice but also in medical education, supervision and research. These models guide nurses to work with observations and interviewing skills in doing an individualized evaluation of every person. It really is a good guide in nursing examination and formulating medical diagnosis. Therefore, obviously both models are valuable in nursing medical practice. Alligood and Marriner-Tomey (2002) declare that conceptual or theoretical types of nurse practice are significant to the field, providing the career with a guide to patient attention and with a general frame of reference point that connects the structural environment to the patterns of habit and human relationships within the organization. Nurses have a unique role to promote health in majority of the setting through the use of these theory in serious healthcare options, community settings, treatment nursing, palliative care, in learning impairment nursing etc. The purpose of both the ideas is providing assistance modified to specific human needs and limits. I would recommend that the idea development of the latest models of and examination will donate to further id of functional theories in medical. Thus, we have to continue our work to develop diverse types of ideas and consider the growth of the medical discipline.

More than 7 000 students trust us to do their work
90% of customers place more than 5 orders with us
Special price $5 /page
Check the price
for your assignment