We accept

Comparison On Higher Education Between China And America Education Essay

The paper is defined out to compare the difference of advanced schooling between China and America from educational ideology. The writer points out that the key differences of higher education between China and America from educational ideology are displayed in entrance selection system, instructing method, idea of private and public university, curriculums, analysis requirements to students, and education on students' personal characteristics and morality. In conclusion, the paper contains that both China and America have to look at different reform actions to advance the grade of respective higher education. Moreover, the integration of these two different higher educations is also very necessary, specifically for the excellence and improvement of higher education of China.

Keywords: Higher Education, Difference, China, America

1 Introduction

China, among the Brick Countries, has shocked depends upon by its swift development in recent generations. America, as NO. 1 super power since the end of the Freezing War, has remained its hegemony in the world in terms of several aspects, including nation-wide politics, economy, technology, technology, culture, advanced schooling, etc. Since higher education is the image of national power of one country and a vital way of cultivating its talents for the future, we Chinese must compare our advanced schooling system with America's from educational ideology and then take benefit of America's strong points and close the space. Advanced schooling is the top source of electric power of cultural development on the ground it cultivates talents and recruiting for the communal development. Therefore, only through continual improvement of higher education can China finally achieve the great rejuvenation of China.

2 Comparison of Higher Education Between China and America

The difference of higher education between China and America can originate from their different ancient and cultural backdrop.

2. 1 History of Higher Education

2. 1. 1 Historical Background

The Chinese advanced schooling of the ancient times is mainly based on Legalist and Confucian ideals. As a matter of fact, Confucius played an important role and has molded the overall Chinese mindset for days gone by 2500 years. The setting of Chinese old advanced schooling was "The Unity of ADVANCED SCHOOLING and Politics"-which demonstrates the combo of government and educational structure. From Han Dynasty, China completed the "rejecting the other colleges of thought and respecting only Confucianism. " Since ancient Chinese Empire regarded higher education as the building blocks of empowering a country, China performed imperial examinations to select the abilities regularly. In simple fact˜Imperial evaluation in Qing Dynasty has shaped the essential and tensing system. The Using of Opium Shares in Humen in 1839 marked the eruption of this First Opium Battle and the beginning of Chinese language modern tines, which, however, finished with the inability of the Qing federal government and then made Chinese intellectuals discover the numerous western advancements in research and technology. This new information influenced the bigger education system and curriculum a lot.

It is widely accepted that the first modern Chinese language university was set up in 1895, right after the Sino-Japanese War (1894-95), which shifted the dominant impact in Asia from China to Japan. Beiyang University or college (now Tianjin College or university) was established in the location of the same name in 1895, accompanied by Qiushi Academy (currently Zhejiang University) in 1897, and Jingshi School (now Beijing College or university) in 1898. By the time the People's Republic of China was founded, there have been 227 higher institutions in China.

The Chinese higher education of contemporary times has gone through substantial changes. From 1967 to 1976, China's Cultural Trend took another toll on China higher education, that was devastated more than every other sector of the country. The enrollment of postsecondary students can be utilized as example to illustrate the impacts. The quantity dropped from 674, 400 to 47, 800. The decline in educational quality was deep. In 1977, Deng Xiaoping made a decision of resuming the Country wide Higher Education Entrance Exam (Gao Kao), having deep impact on Chinese higher education ever sold. In the 1980s on, Chinese language advanced schooling has undergone a series of reforms which may have slowly helped bring improvement.

The historic record of American higher education, however, is silent diverse from that of China on account of its much shorter record (only 236 years).

Puritanism was a religious reform movements that arose within the Church of Great britain in the later sixteenth hundred years. In the first 17th century, thousands of English Puritans resolved in North America, mainly in New Britain. Puritans value the higher education very much. Thus, American advanced schooling in those days was certainly the matrix of Puritan thinking. In 1636, Harvard was founded as the first college or university by vote of the Great and General Court of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, rendering it the oldest institution of higher learning in america.

The Ivy Group is an athletic conference composed of sports groups from eight private companies of advanced schooling in the Northeastern USA, which includes Brown University, Columbia School, Cornell University, Dartmouth University, Harvard School, Princeton School, the University of Pa, and Yale University. The Ivy League, ranks among the top universities in both USA and worldwide, established fact as the symbol of American higher education.

American advanced schooling has gone by using a great enlargement and democratization within the last several decades. In 1900, only four percent of high school graduates attended university. Nowadays, 75 percent of senior high school graduates will continue their educations in schools. American higher education opened to ladies in 1836. A quantity of the men school dealt with a subsidiary of the Women's College or university, such as Barnard College of Columbia School (1889) and Radcliffe University of Harvard University or college (1894). The girls gradually moved into Medical and Legal vocational colleges. In 1969, the Supreme Court mandatorily canceled the black-and-white segregated universities. Congress allocated large amounts of money to compensate the schools of enrolling both dark and white, attempting to improve the racial discrimination in education in the past three hundred years. Corresponding to figures, in 1976, the black youths of institution age in colleges and universities accounted for about 20% and white youths accounted for about 25%.

2. 1. 2 Public History and Culture Tradition

There are three critical indicators which exert extreme influence on North american higher education: Individualism, pragmatism, creative humanities. American higher education system stresses the actual effect and stimulates their college or university students to expose themselves to cultural practice, which accounts for the equal social position of white collars and blue collars in America. The American school has arranged" the improvement of economy", "the study of technology" and "improvement of life standard" alongside one another as three focuses on of higher education. American universities only set up the curriculums and majors get together the needs of population. Moreover, students inspired by American advanced schooling boast full creative humanities soul. For instance, the rise of Information Technology designated by some famous companies in silicon valley such as Microsoft, Facebook, Apple are dominant evidences of the nice result of American advanced schooling of creative humanities heart because all of those entrepreneurs visited American universities, have the advanced schooling and then build the corporation by their extreme creativities. With all these factors contemplated, the American higher education, to some degree, has triggered America's fast development, high technology and economical level.

Chinese Advanced schooling, however, is more collectivism, formalism and Copinism weighed against that of USA. American higher education looks for variety and individuation while Chinese ones run after unity. Therefore, Chinese language students intend to interpret cases regarding to "standard answers" while American ones choose "critical thinking". In China, the trustworthiness of one's Alma Mater can cast a great impact on the communal position, job, even matrimony because the brand of university is meticulously bound to Chinese typical "faceproblem", which easily describe the different social position of white collars and blue collars. Chinese language higher education also emphasizes the reform and improvement of advanced schooling to meet up with the needs of public, economic and medical development, but it changes so little and blindly copies too much from America's instead of creating a perfect system suited to Chinese current condition.

2. 2 Dissimilarities of Higher Education

2. 2. 1 Different Entry Selection System

America has no uniform examinations for enrolling students. The five major elements of admission are Take action/SAT ratings, GPA, College Program, Essay, and Characters of Recommendation. Not all schools require essays or words of suggestion, though they are generally which can increase chances of popularity. American students can pick their major according to their own interests and the programs of development; they may also continuously finish off all curriculums in colleges or choose to have some gap years beyond your campus till they want to get back to school and precede their higher education. To vary from the entry selection standard of China, America has more adaptable and objective one. However, your competition of this Ivy Group is very brutal which demands more to students and it is quite difficult to attain the amount of a good university.

On the contrary, China has a uniform system of selecting students for higher establishments by National ADVANCED SCHOOLING Entrance Evaluation (Gao Kao), once identified asa powerful military single-plank bridge. However, once one step in to the gate of the university, it is easy to be accessible to the amount. Being not the same as the individualism of American students, Chinese students tend to be of collectivism-which means they would choose their major by the typical of common value of Chinese modern culture in stead of the interest. That's why some prevailing majors such as economics, funds, management require much higher score than other majors.

2. 2. 2 Different Coaching Method

In US, teachers' duty is not what they have educated the students, but to help them construct knowledge. The coaching process takes the students' indie thoughts and encourages those to propose something new and various. In the coaching method, emphasizing indefinite coaching methods, teachers encourage the students to participate in the coaching process, and even cause them to become challenge the academics authority. In this type of free and loose environment, students can become more positive on studies and initiative concretion, making use of theory to the practice easily. However in China, many teachers still adopt "force-feed type" coaching method. They educate with sweat streaming, while the students hear drowsily. This kind of teaching method, not only has violated the initial intention of coaching and mastering, but leads students' comprehensive quality and the lifelong research skills to sell at a discount greatly. Instructors sing "the one-man show" in the teaching process phenomenon, while in the American university this phenomenon is incredibly exceptional. Whether students can make great improvement or not, the teaching method takes on an important role.

2. 2. 3 Different Curriculums

In the United States, liberal arts universities are classes emphasizing undergraduate research in the liberal arts. After four years of full-time study generally, students earned the Bachelor of Arts level or a Bachelor of Science level. Liberal Education can be an method of learning that empowers individuals and prepares them to cope with complexity, variety, and change. It provides students with wide-ranging understanding of the wider world (e. g. research, culture, and world) as well as in-depth research in a particular area of interest. A liberal education is designed to make students build-up communal responsibility, strong and transferable intellectual practical skills. Students may possibly also grasp communication, analytical and problem-solving skills, and a shown ability to use knowledge and skills in working.

American University's classes are made of standard education classes, professional foundation courses and elective classes. General education programs take up about 35% -50% and elective classes almost 1/3 among the complete courses, which aspires to strengthen general education and endeavor to cultivate the comprehensive knowledge and skills to resolve functional problems.

Nevertheless, China's higher education, because of the limitation of monetary and methodical level, targets implementing so-called "the professional education"--in other words, "the employment education". It seeks to have an effect on one's value as an instrument. Though the framework of course is close, this content and quality are significantly behind.

General education classes or, we say open public training, including Politics, ideological and Moral course, Army Theory and P. E in Chinese language university, are compulsory to whole students with a unified standard, accounting for approximately 18-24 credits; the applied foundation lessons are mainly in English, Personal computers, Advanced Mathematics, and Chinese language, accounting for approximately 20-26 credits. It is evident implied that the percentage of general education courses is too low, the novelty is insufficient and the system is so untidy. Selective training are neglected or regarded as something unimportant in China, whereas they are essential and essential in American universities as a procedure for getting vulnerability with other understanding of other areas or majors. For want of basic attainment and basic knowledge, Chinese graduates have a tendency to become "workers" however, not "creators". China is internationally popular as "World Stock" because Chinese language higher education focuses the cultivation of labor skills. If China needs to transfer from "World Stock" to "world Designer", there will be quite a distance to travel for the reforms and improvement of curriculums.

2. 2. 4 Different Concept of General public and Private University

America provides more than 1500 public universities and the amount of private ones is up to 1600. Chinese public higher corporations take up 87, whereas the private ones is as low as 13.

In USA, the most prestigious institutions are almost private ones such as Harvard School, Yale School, Princeton College or university, Columbia University, the College or university of Chicago, Duke University and Stanford School. China underestimates the position of private colleges because the enrollment mark is relatively low. However, for want of high skilled private universities, China confronts intense obstacles in the path of the strategy of building up the country by education on the ground that private colleges possess the adaptable management, sufficient money, free academic environment and excellent faculties that happen to be exactly the lack of public colleges.

The income of America private universities is mainly form four programs: the tuition, the government funding, the sponsorship of alumni and the sales and service of patent. The sufficient finance and free educational surrounding make it easy for American private universities to support methodical research, create the new themes and attractive great experts in each field. Additionally, private universities aren't only successful educational institutions but also the cores of market sectors. The rise of Silicon Valley depending on Stanford School and the growth of high-tech industry around Boston attributed to IMF can be illustrated as two cases.

2. 2. 5 Different Analysis Criteria to Students

The standard of inspecting the students of American high companies is the ability to assess and solve the issues, but not the power of mechanised memorizing, which means American students need not cram up before last examinations. Chinese universities, however, adhere to the theory of learning everything by rote, especially for preparation of final examination. What's far worse is the fact that high score becomes the one and only standard of evaluating students in China. It could be predicted that kind of one-sided evaluation standards has written off tons of students' creativities, excitement and wish to do better.

American students are permitted to take some pieces of cards in the set size recording complicated expressions and ideas to attend the final examinations. The aim of examination is very clear in American universities: it is "practice" but not "memorizing". Some expressions even would be outlined on the newspaper because reciting of expressions is not needed, which is so amazing in China. As long as students workout the questions appropriately, they might attain the credited rating. In China, the problem turns out to be opposite. As a matter of known fact, the exam emphasizing mechanical memorizing has seriously ruined the students' eagerness of studies, resulting in excessive focus on 100 % pure theory and overlook the true practice of knowledge.

The credit score of final exam accounts for different percentage in GPA between Chinese universities and American ones. GPA means Quality Point Average and it is a standard method of measuring academic accomplishment. Just how of determining GPA in North american universities is different from that of China. The GPA of American universities are made up of several parts and the ultimate examination is merely one of it. One wouldn't get low GPA even though she or he plays below par so long as the tasks have been finished perfectly in line with the teacher's requirements, because the score of final assessment only occupies 35% in the computation of GPA, however, which closes to 70% generally in most Chinese universities. The typical of American colleges is more objective and good as the analysis to students.

It is high time that China abandoned the old and ossified analysis standards to students. There is still a long way to look before rote learning and test-taking become innovation undoubtedly.

2. 2. 6 Different Education on Students' Personal Characteristics and Morality

In America, volunteering and community service are two important specifications of measuring one's personal characteristics and morality. Though officially not a requirement, many colleges make community service an unofficial requirement for popularity. However, some schools like work experience over community service, and some require that their students also continue community service for some specific range of time to graduate.

American colleges encourage students to take part in the cultural and by which raise their citizen consciousness. Volunteering is also an important part while enterprises using new staffs, so American students are very prepared to be volunteers. Certain academics honor societies such as Delta Epsilon Sigma have turned down 4. 0 GPA students that lacked community service experience on the applications because they honor community service a lot.

In China, volunteering and community service are not as important as in America. Chinese universities haven't set the time of volunteering and community as one of the requirements of getting the diploma. However, the knowing of volunteering and community has increased by leaps and bounds. For example, 2008 Beijing Olympic Video games and 2010 Shanghai World Expo has observed the function of volunteers, and the majority of them are college or university students. In order to continue the volunteering sprit of 2010 Shanghai World Expo, Shanghai has create many city volunteers service stations in the tourist attractions to supply the service for travelers, which give you a good possibility to university students. Rare as interpersonal activities are in China, Chinese university has endeavored to increase the personal characteristics and morality by causing more volunteering chances.

3 Prospective of China and American Higher Education

3. 1 Reform Steps for Chinese language Higher Education

Education reform in China has reached a fresh and crucial level. The driving drive is the necessity to produce an extremely knowledgeable workforce outfitted to handle the challenges of an economy that is not only growing extremely swiftly, but also becoming more and more diversified and complex.

The latest reforms are specified in a thorough plan formally called "State Suggestions for Medium-to-Long-Term Education Reform and Development Plan between 2010 and 2020, " otherwise known as the Development Plan. 1 Another round of nationwide debate of the Development Plan has just been completed, plus more than 30, 000 ideas were collected, reflecting national involvement in this important issue. This plan is extensive and comprehensive, and is dependant on studies of various educational models.

Two aspects for higher education reform are key: a leisure of central control, and checking of the school entrance process. The Development Plan specifically demands the government release a central control, give colleges autonomy, and allow presidents and faculty to perform their universities.

The Development Plan states that it'll change from the "one-exam-decides-all" method to a thorough evaluation of a student all together person using multiple exams and factors.

The plan is divided into four sections. Each section addresses several chapters and each section includes numerous issues. Section One describes the plan's overall strategy. Section Two lays out missions to accomplish and goals to accomplish. Section Three outlines the reform of the educational infrastructure. Section Four provides measurements to ensure implementation. Six chapters are specialized in specific measures, which include the following: strengthening the quality of teaching faculty; increasing the government money of education to 4% of GDP by 2012; completing education regulations; and guaranteeing every step of the reform satisfies the laws and regulations. In order to complete these missions and goals, the Development Plan encourages educational institutions to create their own reform programs and guidelines. (Guo-hua Wang, April 20, 2010)

3. 2 Reform Methods for American Higher Education

In his Talk about of the Union address, Leader Obama laid out a blueprint for an market that's created to last - an overall economy built on American processing, North american energy, skills for American staff, and a renewal of American principles. As an important part of keeping the American promises alive, the Chief executive called for an extensive method of tackling rising college or university costs. In today's global current economic climate, a school education is no more just a privilege for a few, but instead a prerequisite for everyone.

Reforming student aid to market affordability and value: To help keep tuition from spiraling too much and drive higher value, the Leader will propose reforms to federal government campus-based air programs to transfer aid away from colleges that fail to keep net tuition down, and toward those colleges and universities that do their fair share to keep tuition affordable, provide good value, and serve needy students well. These changes in federal government help to campuses will leverage $10 billion yearly to keep tuition down.

Creating a Race to the very best for college affordability and completion: The leader will create bonuses for states and colleges to keep costs in order through the $1billion investment in a new challenge to areas to spur advanced schooling reform centered on affordability and advanced outcomes across point out universites and colleges.

A first on earth competition to model invention and quality on college campuses: The president will make investments $55 million in a fresh First on the globe competition, to support the public and private universities and non-profit organizations as they work to develop and test the next breakthrough strategy that will supercharge higher education attainment and college student outcomes

Better data for young families choose the right college to them: The leader will require a College Scorecard for everyone degree-granting institutions, made to supply the essential information about school costs, graduation rates, and potential revenue, all in an easy-to-read format that will assist students and family members choose a college that is suitable with their needs, costed affordably and regular with their profession and educational goals.

Federal support to take on university costs: The leader has already made the biggest investments in college student aid since the G. I Charge through increases to the Pell give, and by shoring up the direct loan and income-based repayment programs.

This reform will compensate colleges that are succeeding in meeting the following principles:

Setting in charge tuition policy, offering relatively lower online tuition prices and/or restraining tuition growth.

Providing good value to students and young families, offering quality education and training that prepares graduates to acquire employment and repay their lending options.

3) Serving low-income students, enrolling and graduating relatively higher amounts of Pell-eligible students. ( The White House, Office of the Press Secretary, January 27, 2012)

4 Integration of Chinese language and American Higher Education

China launched curriculum and coaching reform in the 1990s, leading to great desire for studies of American university or college curriculum reforms and instructional systems. When China launched the "211 Project" and "985 Task, " this dished up as a great spur to Chinese studies of American research colleges.

New York and Duke School are building campuses in Shanghai, offering full-time programs to students there, and executive education courses already are a proven success, Harvard's Senior Executive Program in Shanghai among them. There were many joint venture programs with American universities on the campuses of Chinese higher corporations; however, the development toward larger-scale initiatives seems clear.

In the mean time, America also needs to learn from China. America has always taken a laissez-faire method of higher education-in many ways, with positive results. But it may wish to consider whether new competition justifies a fresh way. China may soon outpace the United States not only in the amount of college or university graduates it produces, but also in the world-class colleges it generates. From 1995 to 2000, degrees of the Chinese authorities invested about $20-billion in go for universities to boost their facilities and curricula. In the following years, 38 of these universities received additional money. For instance, two top companies, Peking University and Tsinghua University, each received $225-million from 1999 to 2003.

American college leaders should prepare themselves psychologically for a world when a key success factor will be partnerships with Asian colleges. The good news is that Asian companies welcome such new partnerships.

5. Conclusion

Higher Education is the backbone of the country on the floor of sustaining its development through fostering abilities. Without any shadow of question, both China and America lay great focus on advanced schooling, by different form and method, though. China, among the emerging power in the Asian-Pacific region, ought to learn a great deal from America, including advanced schooling, in terms of entrance selection system, private colleges, the positioning of higher educational function, evaluation standards to students and the training to students' personal characteristics and morality and campus culture. Both these two countries make great responsibility to raised educational reform in the future to confront the brutal competition.

More than 7 000 students trust us to do their work
90% of customers place more than 5 orders with us
Special price $5 /page
Check the price
for your assignment